Posted by FrankTheTank1181
IMO the judges as a whole got it right.
No...it was ruled a Draw by default.
As a whole, the judges couldn't agree on a damn thing. 3 judges scored it 3 different ways. "As a whole" isn't applicable in this situation.
_______________________________________
TWITTER: @THE_FLEEK and @MMAPlayground
"I'm like the superhero coming in with the anti-bullsh*t." - Nick Diaz
just fyi that was the hot bout
Posted by FrankTheTank1181
Posted by telnights
Posted by FrankTheTank1181
I thought it was a draw, the outcome was a draw, so the judges, as a whole, got it right...
Because it ended the way you thought it should have all the judges got it right? Is that you Keith Kizer?
I never said every judge got it right, I said the judges "As A Whole" got it right, can you not see the difference or do you enjoy nit picking?
Your welcome to think that but clearly you don't understand what a majority draw is.
_______________________________________
MMA Playground Mod
Telnights
MMAplayground Rules
Posted by telnights
Posted by FrankTheTank1181
Posted by telnights
Posted by FrankTheTank1181
I thought it was a draw, the outcome was a draw, so the judges, as a whole, got it right...
Because it ended the way you thought it should have all the judges got it right? Is that you Keith Kizer?
I never said every judge got it right, I said the judges "As A Whole" got it right, can you not see the difference or do you enjoy nit picking?
Your welcome to think that but clearly you don't understand what a majority draw is.
One of three isn't "A Whole" it is a minority.
how about instead of discussing the complexities of the english language, we discuss the actual fight guys
Posted by Franklinfan47
how about instead of discussing the complexities of the english language, we discuss the actual fight guys
Haha...alright. I think that there is no way that the judges should have been that split on that fight. It was a close fight, but still...
One judge said Maynard, the other said Edgar and the other said F@#$ It let 'em figure it out on the playground.
Posted by sbulldavid
One judge said Maynard, the other said Edgar and the other said F@#$ It let 'em figure it out on the playground.
Best comment on this thread
I can see the 48-46 Maynard with him winning round 1/10-8 3/10-9 and 5/10-9. I can see the 47-47 draw with Edgar winning 2/4/5 10-9. But I cant see 48-46 for Edgar.
_______________________________________
MMA Playground Mod
Telnights
MMAplayground Rules
Ya they really shouldnt let judges smoke crack before fights. 48-46 Edgar is a pipe dream.
I think a lot of people are heavily weighing the First Round for Maynard. It was Def. a 10-8 round but you can't really give the next 4 rounds to Gray. Look at the fight from a whole and dont let the first round influence your decision.
I think it should have been a draw.
Pettis vs. Edgar will be fireworks.