MMAPlayground.com

Forum Index > MMA General > General MMA Talk
Pound for Pound rankings   [View Full Version]
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6
strikefirstgear » Posted 1/15/07 1:29:00PM

For this list:

1. GSP ( I think the most well rounded fighter out there)
2. Fedor (cuz it's a pound for pound)
3. Shogun
4. Lidell
5. Wandy or Crop Cop

Of course this is a very subjective list. Best p4p of all time would be a different story.

peppermintfatty » Posted 1/24/07 5:23:00PM

1. Georges St. Pierre
2. Fedor Emelianenko
3. Chuck Liddell
4. B.J. Penn
5. Shogun Rua

If this were expanded beyond UFC and Pride I would have Kid Yamamoto as #1.

pv3Hpv3p » Posted 1/24/07 6:08:00PM

1. Giant Silva
2. Bonnar
3. Sam Hoger
4. Baroni
5. Forrest











Sorry I couldn't help myself, lol

1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Shogun
4. Big Nog
5. Chuck

(honerable mention to Gomi, only because I think sometimes his ground game isn't there. And I will also add Lindland, the most under-rated fighter in the world (Good luck with Fedor though))

tffdwg38 » Posted 1/24/07 3:09:00PM

1.. fedor of course
2. crocop
3. liddel
4. gsp
5. wandy

nickcuc547 » Posted 1/27/07 12:52:00PM

1.Fedor
2.GSP
3.Liddell
4.Gomi
5.Hughes

Shogun, Cro Cop, Noguera, Penn and Wandy would be my next 5

tffdwg38 » Posted 1/24/07 3:09:00PM

fedor is def #1

xchickox » Posted 1/26/07 10:31:00AM

i think when people are rating the top fighters pound for pound they seem to forget a lot of the lighter weight fighters...

...like anderson silva, rich franklin, sean sherk, matt hughes

and there's a lot of others

swazymaq » Posted 1/30/07 11:59:00AM

I reckon no one knows what Pound for Pound is?
Chuck does not belong on that list!
A good list is

Fedor
Kid Yamamoto
Gomi
GSP
Shinichi Kojima
Mamoru Yamaguchi
Cro-Cop
Shogun
BJ Penn
Little Nog

swazymaq » Posted 1/30/07 11:59:00AM

Fedor
Kid Yamamoto
Shinichi Kojima
Gomi
GSP
Mamoru Yamaguchi
Cro-Cop
Shogun
BJ Penn
Little Nog

Jeffanori-Gomi » Posted 1/24/07 3:29:00PM

1. Kid yamamato
2. BJ Penn
3. Fedor
4. Wandy/shogun
5. GSP

Honorable mentions, Gomi, Nogs, Liddell, and..

tuthemaxx » Posted 1/27/07 6:56:00PM

1.Fedor
2.Gsp
3.Chuck
4.Wandy
5.Shogun

Soon to be Discused
1 Vera
2 Tyson Griffin
3 Rachad Evans
4 Diego
5 Denis Kang

Never to be Discused
Loudon Sincad
Butterbean
You fill in the rest

shawneth » Posted 1/24/07 5:49:00PM

I dont like Pound 4 Pound rankings.... they are more opinions then MMA Weekly rankings are... it truly is impossible to judge two people who will never fight, so im not even gonna start.

gspfan31 » Posted 1/25/07 12:56:00AM

fedor
shogun
gomi
gsp
chuck/wandy

Jeffanori-Gomi » Posted 1/24/07 3:29:00PM


Posted by Gladiator

my greatest pound 4 pound list would go like this:

1)Jorge Gurgel

2)Danni Abbadi

3)Koji Oishi

4)Ross Pointon

5)Kevin Jordan



what about tank abbot, and Ogawa?

GladE8R » Posted 2/1/07 2:39:00PM

Fedor (but I will move him if he doesnt fight someone for a title or someone ranked in the top 5 HW's soon)
Chuck
Cro Cop
W. Silva
GSP or Gomi or Shogun(cant decide)

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6


[View Full Version of this Page]