For this list:
1. GSP ( I think the most well rounded fighter out there)
2. Fedor (cuz it's a pound for pound)
3. Shogun
4. Lidell
5. Wandy or Crop Cop
Of course this is a very subjective list. Best p4p of all time would be a different story.
1. Georges St. Pierre
2. Fedor Emelianenko
3. Chuck Liddell
4. B.J. Penn
5. Shogun Rua
If this were expanded beyond UFC and Pride I would have Kid Yamamoto as #1.
1. Giant Silva
2. Bonnar
3. Sam Hoger
4. Baroni
5. Forrest
Sorry I couldn't help myself, lol
1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Shogun
4. Big Nog
5. Chuck
(honerable mention to Gomi, only because I think sometimes his ground game isn't there. And I will also add Lindland, the most under-rated fighter in the world (Good luck with Fedor though))
1.. fedor of course
2. crocop
3. liddel
4. gsp
5. wandy
1.Fedor
2.GSP
3.Liddell
4.Gomi
5.Hughes
Shogun, Cro Cop, Noguera, Penn and Wandy would be my next 5
fedor is def #1
i think when people are rating the top fighters pound for pound they seem to forget a lot of the lighter weight fighters...
...like anderson silva, rich franklin, sean sherk, matt hughes
and there's a lot of others
I reckon no one knows what Pound for Pound is?
Chuck does not belong on that list!
A good list is
Fedor
Kid Yamamoto
Gomi
GSP
Shinichi Kojima
Mamoru Yamaguchi
Cro-Cop
Shogun
BJ Penn
Little Nog
Fedor
Kid Yamamoto
Shinichi Kojima
Gomi
GSP
Mamoru Yamaguchi
Cro-Cop
Shogun
BJ Penn
Little Nog
1. Kid yamamato
2. BJ Penn
3. Fedor
4. Wandy/shogun
5. GSP
Honorable mentions, Gomi, Nogs, Liddell, and..
1.Fedor
2.Gsp
3.Chuck
4.Wandy
5.Shogun
Soon to be Discused
1 Vera
2 Tyson Griffin
3 Rachad Evans
4 Diego
5 Denis Kang
Never to be Discused
Loudon Sincad
Butterbean
You fill in the rest
I dont like Pound 4 Pound rankings.... they are more opinions then MMA Weekly rankings are... it truly is impossible to judge two people who will never fight, so im not even gonna start.
fedor
shogun
gomi
gsp
chuck/wandy
Posted by Gladiator
my greatest pound 4 pound list would go like this:
1)Jorge Gurgel
2)Danni Abbadi
3)Koji Oishi
4)Ross Pointon
5)Kevin Jordan
what about tank abbot, and Ogawa?
Fedor (but I will move him if he doesnt fight someone for a title or someone ranked in the top 5 HW's soon)
Chuck
Cro Cop
W. Silva
GSP or Gomi or Shogun(cant decide)