| |
Diaz vs gomi ruling !!!????
Diaz vs gomi ruling !!!???? |
| Posted By |
Message |
He's Back...
Career record: 163-86
Season: 0-0 (#8367)
Location: Sacramento, CA
|
I just think that this "commission" is a great thing, and necessary for the sport, but there also has to be some consistency to it as well. Cant have someone getting a fight overturned, and Royce still has his win, solely because of his last name. Definitely not defending fighters who test positive for ANYTHING, thats for sure...
_______________________________________
Riding the James Thompson WarWagon all the way to the top!
Official James Thompson Forums
*RETIRED*
|
|
Post #16 6/30/07 7:36:56PM
|
|
|
The Dancing Mod
Career record: 181-125
Season: 18-12 (#4263)
Location: Maryland
|
Dude, have you been smokin the ganja??
_______________________________________
I would like to direct this to the distinguished members of the panel: You lousy corksuckers. You have violated my farging rights. Dis somanumbatching country was founded so that the liberties of common patriotic citizens like me could not be taken away by a bunch of fargin' iceholes... like yourselves.
|
|
Post #17 6/30/07 8:10:07PM
|
johny_rotten
Standup Guy
Career record: 98-57
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Location:
|
Posted by rcg916
I just think that this "commission" is a great thing, and necessary for the sport, but there also has to be some consistency to it as well. Cant have someone getting a fight overturned, and Royce still has his win, solely because of his last name. Definitely not defending fighters who test positive for ANYTHING, thats for sure...
apparently in California it isn't in the MMA bi-laws to be able to over turn the result of a fight due to steroids. I am unsure if it was legal for Pride to due that since the NSAC hasn't done that in the past. Does any have a link to a story of this when it took place 8 YEARS AGO to see if Pride changed the status or did Nevada?
|
|
Post #18 6/30/07 8:55:16PM
|
Learning to Sprawl
Career record: 145-83
Season: 19-13 (#3367)
Location: Fairbanks, Alaska
|
why should we respect laws that are ******* bullshit
|
|
Post #19 7/1/07 1:10:42AM
|
xkillerbx
Learning to Sprawl
Career record: 138-77
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Location:
|
Posted by johny_rotten
Posted by ProfessorChaos
Weed is illegal
END THREAD
So are steroids, and they actually enhance performance, but descions for fighters with those in their system weren't overruled. See Tim vs McGee, Randy vs Barnett, Rocye vs Sak and so on.
Sylvia/McGee and Couture/Barnett were both before the rule was in place to overturn the decision based on illegal substances. Gracie/Sakuraba was fought in California where there also is no rule in place to overturn a decision.
|
|
Post #20 7/1/07 1:29:31AM
|
xkillerbx
Learning to Sprawl
Career record: 138-77
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Location:
|
Posted by Collinreuter
why should we respect laws that are ******* bullshit
Because if you want to get a license to fight in Nevada, you have to follow their rules. It's no secret, weed is illegal, the fact that the law is bullshit is irrelevant. Nick Diaz knew the rules and decided to break them anyway. It's nobody's fault but his own.
|
|
Post #21 7/1/07 1:32:06AM
|
Boondock Saints Mod
Career record: 197-119
Season: 27-13 (#363)
Location: California
|
Posted by Mastodon2
Posted by rcg916
Marijuana is not performance enhancing, if anything it would make you drag ass. Also, despite what people keep saying, marijuana also HEIGHTENS SENSITIVITY to touch... That makes it pretty tough to claim that it also numbs you.
Im sorry but that is not the case; THC is a depressant, it gets into the Synapases around your body and in your brain, and blocks neurotransmitters, deadening the senses of touch and pain etc. In this aspect, it works just like Acohol. You may not smoke, but I'm sure you've been drunk - you get that rubber fingered, numb feeling because of the synapses allover your body being blocked. If you've ever seen drunk people fight, you will know that the lack of pain they experience allows them to absorb all kinds of punishment, drunk people fight on because they dont realise how much damage they are taking. THC works in just the same way.
So to summarise, THC (from Marijuana, or whatever source) does not "heighten sensitivity", it kills it, and it can be used as a performance enhancer.
I agree, Diaz gave a radio interview after the commision hearing, and said he didn't smoke it. He took a straight THC paste on his food. he didn't explain why though, but it does numb pain. I want a rematch, but Diaz had his orbiatal eye socket bone broken in the fight, and just kept coming. Is he a tough guy, absolutely, but it does cast some doubt on why his pain threshold was so high. It also explains why his THC count( 175) was so ridiculously high.Here is a a quick article from Ufc junkie after the hearing that explains more about why the commision overturned the decision.
Nick Diaz’s Win Over Takanori Gomi Ruled a No-Contest
Posted by UFC Junkie on April 10, 2007 at 5:32 pm ET
Nick Diaz Former UFC fighter Nick Diaz’s upset victory over PRIDE Fighting Championships’ lightweight champion Takanori Gomi in a recent non-title fight has been ruled a no-contest because of his failed drug test, according to MMAWeekly.com.
Diaz, who scored a submission victory via gogoplata over Gomi at PRIDE 33, tested positive for marijuana in his post-fight drug test at the February event. Today, the Nevada State Athletic Commission erased the win from his record and also suspended Diaz for six months from the date of his fight and fined him $3,000.
Diaz had earned $15,000 for the fight.
The severity of the punishment resulted largely from the NSAC’s belief that Diaz was under the influence of the drug the night of the fight, which according to the NSAC’s chair commissioner (in a awkward-sounding statement), helped him dull pain and assisted in the win.
According to MMAWeekly.com:
Apparently, the commission felt that the level for which Diaz tested at, 175, was a considering factor in his performance during the fight. Dr. Tony Alamo, the Commission’s Chair, said that a result of 15 is considered positive, but that the NSAC has a threshold of 50 to test positive for THC and that they “feel very comfortable that everyone that tests positive [in Nevada] is truly positive.“
Alamo went on to say, “Mr. Diaz was 175. This creates a unique situation. I was there at this fight and believe that you were intoxicated and… that it made you numb to the pain. Did it help you win? I think it did.“
The failed test marred what had been Diaz’s biggest win to date.
Now, given today’s ruling, the victory will be wiped from his record completely and changed to a no-contest. The 23-year-old Cesar Gracie Jiu-Jitsu student now owns a 14-6 record, including a 6-4 mark in the UFC.
For more information about today’s hearing, including Joe Pearson’s (marijuana) and Kit Cope’s (performance-enhancing agent) suspensions from failed tests at a Jan. 20 World Extreme Cagefighting event, head over to MMAWeekly.com.
This entry is filed under PRIDE, Nick Diaz, Kit Cope, World Extreme Cagefighting, Takanori Gomi, Joe Pearson
Last edited 7/1/07 4:18AM by hippysmacker
Edit note/reason: n/a
_______________________________________
“Never violate a woman, nor harm a child. Do not lie, cheat or steal. These things are for lesser men. Protect the weak against the evil strong. And never allow thoughts of gain to lead you into the pursuit of evil. Never back away from an enemy. Either fight or surrender. It is not enough to say I will not be evil. Evil must be fought wherever it is found.”
The Iron Code
|
|
Post #22 7/1/07 4:16:05AM
|
keith-hackney1
Belt Contender
Career record: 164-136
Season: 23-17 (#2009)
Location: hampshire, england
|
Are you guys with me on this one, yes, weed is a drug, weed is classed as illegal, but my whole point to this no ruling to diaz is the fact that weed is something that could be inhaled from a smoke filled bar or from a friends house or something like that. Whereas with steroids thats a completely different case, its not likely that steriods are to be accidently inhaled or accidently injected into your body.
As far as i am aware weed is not a performance inhancing drug, Its more likely to make you feel lazy and spaced out, its not gonna make you want to fight a fast paced explosive fight with japans lightweight champion of the world is it ???
Diaz was robbed of an impressive win that put him in the top 3, and i tell you guys, the rematch will go down the same way, gomi is a striker in mma, diaz will win again and take his well deserved spot at the top.
|
|
Post #23 7/1/07 11:26:40AM
|
Mastodon2
MMA Sensei
Career record: 169-96
Season: 18-11 (#5069)
Location: Newcastle England
|
Posted by keith-hackney1
Are you guys with me on this one, yes, weed is a drug, weed is classed as illegal, but my whole point to this no ruling to diaz is the fact that weed is something that could be inhaled from a smoke filled bar or from a friends house or something like that. Whereas with steroids thats a completely different case, its not likely that steriods are to be accidently inhaled or accidently injected into your body.
As far as i am aware weed is not a performance inhancing drug, Its more likely to make you feel lazy and spaced out, its not gonna make you want to fight a fast paced explosive fight with japans lightweight champion of the world is it ???
Diaz was robbed of an impressive win that put him in the top 3, and i tell you guys, the rematch will go down the same way, gomi is a striker in mma, diaz will win again and take his well deserved spot at the top.
They tested Diaz's THC levels, they said "15 is positive, Diaz had 175", so we can deduce that anything below 15 (in whatever arbitrary unit they measure it by) is a pass, so this will make sure that people dont get caught by going out clubbing, or to bars etc. Ive been out clubbing recently, so my THC level is probably 2 or 3 or this Unit, but smoking it obviously raises someones THC levels to higher than 15, so they can be sure that with reasonable certainty that people have been abusing Cannabis in some form. Diaz had a level of 175. This is a gargantuan amount, if 15 is considered the failure limit for the test.
|
|
Post #24 7/1/07 12:01:36PM
|
KYGUY07
In Full Mount
Career record: 178-87
Season: 27-13 (#1134)
Location: KY
|
The way i see it is you shouldnt overturn a decison on weed, if your not gonna overturn a decison when someone was on steroids. its just ridiculous.
|
|
Post #25 7/1/07 1:59:58PM
|
keith-hackney1
Belt Contender
Career record: 164-136
Season: 23-17 (#2009)
Location: hampshire, england
|
Whats thc levels???
|
|
Post #26 7/1/07 2:16:14PM
|
Boondock Saints Mod
Career record: 197-119
Season: 27-13 (#363)
Location: California
|
Posted by KYGUY07
The way i see it is you shouldnt overturn a decison on weed, if your not gonna overturn a decison when someone was on steroids. its just ridiculous.
I see your point , but 2 wrongs don't make a right. If my car was stolen , and the thief was never caught, i wouldn't want anyones else's car thief to get away with it either.Also, THC is Tetrahydrocannabinol, the main pyschactive ingredient in marijuana. In other words, it's what gets you high.
_______________________________________
“Never violate a woman, nor harm a child. Do not lie, cheat or steal. These things are for lesser men. Protect the weak against the evil strong. And never allow thoughts of gain to lead you into the pursuit of evil. Never back away from an enemy. Either fight or surrender. It is not enough to say I will not be evil. Evil must be fought wherever it is found.”
The Iron Code
|
|
Post #27 7/1/07 2:20:39PM
|
keith-hackney1
Belt Contender
Career record: 164-136
Season: 23-17 (#2009)
Location: hampshire, england
|
Thanks for explanation, is it standard for all mma athletes to be tested on their thc levels after a fight or would someone from nsac been tipped off on diaz's condition.??
Im really behind the times you guys, been a long couple of weeks at work, i just saw in a response the words, "why let someone off who has taken steroids" ...... Does that mean that a has been gracie still gets the undeserved victory that the gracie brothers paid k1 judges to rule in royces favour and rob sak ??? ..Oh no, what next !!
|
|
Post #28 7/1/07 2:30:40PM
|
Boondock Saints Mod
Career record: 197-119
Season: 27-13 (#363)
Location: California
|
they get tested before and after the fight
_______________________________________
“Never violate a woman, nor harm a child. Do not lie, cheat or steal. These things are for lesser men. Protect the weak against the evil strong. And never allow thoughts of gain to lead you into the pursuit of evil. Never back away from an enemy. Either fight or surrender. It is not enough to say I will not be evil. Evil must be fought wherever it is found.”
The Iron Code
|
|
Post #29 7/1/07 2:33:13PM
|
Aether
MMA Sensei
Career record: 107-74
Season: 25-15 (#1576)
Location: Canada
|
Don't take this the wrong way kaduey but you're badly misinformed about this. There is no chance in hell that anyone is going to be hanging around people who are smoking pot and test positive for THC 2 days later, hell 5 minutes later. The concentration of smoke floating around in the open air isn't close to enough to put the amount of THC required for a positive test into your system. On top of that fact, the majority of the smoke floating around in the air will already have been inhaled and exhaled, meaning the vast majority of the THC has already been absorbed into the bloodstream of whoever smoked it to begin with.
You can argue this from a lot of different angles, but that just isn't one of them. He did willingly take the drug, now whether you believe the punishment fits the crime, or whether it should even constitute a crime is another matter, but he DID do the drug. Apparently he actually ATE it as opposed to smoking it, which makes all of this make a lot more sense to me. His levels were through the roof, when you eat pot it actually takes a much larger amount to get you high.... it also gives you an all-around body high as opposed to a head high as well as lasting for a significantly longer period of time which again makes a lot of sense if his intention really was to use it as a pain-killer.
-EDIT-
As for your question of do they get tested for THC, yes, everyone gets tested the same way. The tests aren't designed to search for a specific kind of drug or another, they simply look at what chemicals are there that are not naturally present in human blood, so one blood test will find cocaine/thc/anabolic steroids/whatever... no one would've had to have been tipped off, it would just show up regardless.
Last edited 7/1/07 5:15PM by Aether
Edit note/reason: n/a
|
|
Post #30 7/1/07 5:12:21PM
|
|
|
|
