Today's Topics Unanswered Topics Avatar Bets Search PM's My Props Member Directory Premium Members Recent Polls Subscriptions Rules
 
Sponsors
 

Once a critic, Dana White now a fan of veteran ref John McCarthy

Once a critic, Dana White now a fan of veteran ref John McCarthy
Posted By Message

FastKnockout
Heavyweight Champ

FastKnockout Avatar
6





Career record: 1473-814
Season: 45-20 (#336)
Bankroll: $2,805 (#380)
Location: Mississippi
1550
10807 posts
Joined 9/10
There was a time when UFC President Dana White and John McCarthy weren’t on each other’s Christmas lists, to put it nicely.

Link

Post #1   12/15/13 11:20:10AM   

Fearless Leader

OnyxShadow Avatar
13












Career record: 1696-821
Season: 46-19 (#65)
Bankroll: $2,307 (#718)
Location: Texas
162
332 posts
Joined 1/08
I would be surprised if White ever had a problem with McCarthy's ref work which is arguably the best there is. I suspect it has a lot more to do with Big John's outspokenness outside the ring.

Post #2   12/15/13 1:38:03PM   

jae_1833
Heavyweight Champ

jae_1833 Avatar
5




Career record: 2332-1467
Season: 42-23 (#312)
Bankroll: $3,445 (#179)
Location: California
978
7646 posts
Joined 7/07
That's what it is, all know McCarthy is a great Ref...he has been very involved in the way the sport has grown, very vocal about the rules and politics of it all. That has put them at odds with each other on occasion.

Post #3   12/15/13 1:52:08PM   

40ouncetpkid
In Full Mount

40ouncetpkid Avatar
1
Career record: 250-155
Season: 10-13 (#1457)
Bankroll: $685 (#1535)
Location: Trailer Park
117
734 posts
Joined 5/11
It did seem awhile back like Big John wasnt reffing UFC fights. It wasnt like any tine recently but maybe a few years back it felt like he disappeared.

Post #4   12/15/13 2:00:29PM   

MODular Approach

grappler0000 Avatar
24























Career record: 2518-1372
Season: 45-20 (#89)
Bankroll: $2,408 (#662)
Location:
2436
9911 posts
Joined 3/07

Posted by 40ouncetpkid

It did seem awhile back like Big John wasnt reffing UFC fights. It wasnt like any tine recently but maybe a few years back it felt like he disappeared.



Part of that is the fact that he's not licensed in Nevada, where a large number of fights happen. And Nevada also supplies the refs for any events that don't have sanctioning in the region. IIRC Big John pissed off Kizer.

Post #5   12/15/13 2:10:58PM   

Human/Sloth Hybrid

VILLIN Avatar
4



Career record: 1648-959
Season: 46-19 (#117)
Bankroll: $2,915 (#310)
Location: Dartmouth, NS
118
197 posts
Joined 12/09
McCarthy went a little loopy in the head during the whole Affliction/WAMMA debacle. I've never liked the way he officiates. In my opinion the ref should be as invisible as possible so the fighters' skills are what control the outcome. John's loud, in-your-face style puts him far too much into the limelight and detracts from the fighters. The ref is supposed to be in there to enforce the rules and protect the fighters not to be a 'character' for the cameras.

Post #6   12/15/13 5:29:13PM   

Fearless Leader

OnyxShadow Avatar
13












Career record: 1696-821
Season: 46-19 (#65)
Bankroll: $2,307 (#718)
Location: Texas
162
332 posts
Joined 1/08

Posted by VILLIN

McCarthy went a little loopy in the head during the whole Affliction/WAMMA debacle. I've never liked the way he officiates. In my opinion the ref should be as invisible as possible so the fighters' skills are what control the outcome. John's loud, in-your-face style puts him far too much into the limelight and detracts from the fighters. The ref is supposed to be in there to enforce the rules and protect the fighters not to be a 'character' for the cameras.



You mean the 2 second "Let's get it on" schtick followed by up to 15 minutes of flawless and unobtrusive refereeing?

Post #7   12/15/13 8:04:53PM   

Come at me bro

Bubbles Avatar
5




Career record: 1120-670
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
1460
9368 posts
Joined 10/09

Posted by OnyxShadow


Posted by VILLIN

McCarthy went a little loopy in the head during the whole Affliction/WAMMA debacle. I've never liked the way he officiates. In my opinion the ref should be as invisible as possible so the fighters' skills are what control the outcome. John's loud, in-your-face style puts him far too much into the limelight and detracts from the fighters. The ref is supposed to be in there to enforce the rules and protect the fighters not to be a 'character' for the cameras.



You mean the 2 second "Let's get it on" schtick followed by up to 15 minutes of flawless and unobtrusive refereeing?


or creating a school for refs and judges? Or speaking out on how inept and incompetent NSAC and Keizer is?

_______________________________________
The best cure for insomnia is a lot of sex. Even if it doesn't end up putting you to sleep, you don't mind so much

Men be careful, female sexual predators are using a date rape drug called a Blowjob to trap men into scams called relationships.

Post #8   12/15/13 8:48:12PM   

#5 - All Time Pick%

Shawn91111 Avatar
16















Career record: 2416-1256
Season: 43-22 (#387)
Bankroll: $6,331 (#44)
Location: New York
1014
5058 posts
Joined 9/07

Posted by Bubbles


Posted by OnyxShadow


Posted by VILLIN

McCarthy went a little loopy in the head during the whole Affliction/WAMMA debacle. I've never liked the way he officiates. In my opinion the ref should be as invisible as possible so the fighters' skills are what control the outcome. John's loud, in-your-face style puts him far too much into the limelight and detracts from the fighters. The ref is supposed to be in there to enforce the rules and protect the fighters not to be a 'character' for the cameras.



You mean the 2 second "Let's get it on" schtick followed by up to 15 minutes of flawless and unobtrusive refereeing?


or creating a school for refs and judges? Or speaking out on how inept and incompetent NSAC and Keizer is?



Yes all of that

_______________________________________
Men be careful, Bubbles, the "sexual predator" is using a date rape drug called a Blowjob to trap men into scams called relationships.

#5 - All Time Pick% - Suck it Bythar!

Post #9   12/15/13 8:59:23PM   

Human/Sloth Hybrid

VILLIN Avatar
4



Career record: 1648-959
Season: 46-19 (#117)
Bankroll: $2,915 (#310)
Location: Dartmouth, NS
118
197 posts
Joined 12/09

Posted by OnyxShadow


Posted by VILLIN

McCarthy went a little loopy in the head during the whole Affliction/WAMMA debacle. I've never liked the way he officiates. In my opinion the ref should be as invisible as possible so the fighters' skills are what control the outcome. John's loud, in-your-face style puts him far too much into the limelight and detracts from the fighters. The ref is supposed to be in there to enforce the rules and protect the fighters not to be a 'character' for the cameras.



You mean the 2 second "Let's get it on" schtick followed by up to 15 minutes of flawless and unobtrusive refereeing?



No I mean the constant shouting of commands at the fighters, the lectures he feels the need to give one of the fighters every time he separates the action and the several injuries he has caused by full out tackling fighters while stopping a fight. I don't deny that he makes less screw ups than other referees but you'd have to be blind and deaf to think he's unobtrusive.

Post #10   12/15/13 9:01:58PM   

Michael_Corleone
In Full Mount

Michael_Corleone Avatar
Career record: 862-449
Season: 42-23 (#172)
Bankroll: $445 (#1606)
Location: Private
186
771 posts
Joined 4/11

Posted by VILLIN

McCarthy went a little loopy in the head during the whole Affliction/WAMMA debacle. I've never liked the way he officiates. In my opinion the ref should be as invisible as possible so the fighters' skills are what control the outcome. John's loud, in-your-face style puts him far too much into the limelight and detracts from the fighters. The ref is supposed to be in there to enforce the rules and protect the fighters not to be a 'character' for the cameras.




To each his own, but I would prefer a vocal and firm referee 10 times out of 10 over a silent and awkward referee.

Last edited 12/16/13 1:48AM by michael_corleone
Edit note/reason: n/a

Post #11   12/16/13 1:47:31AM   

bjj1605
Heavyweight Champ

bjj1605 Avatar
6





Career record: 1402-821
Season: 26-16 (#1141)
Bankroll: $1,001 (#1415)
Location: Chicago
671
3172 posts
Joined 10/07
I agree that obtrusive referrers are bad, but I disagree that McCarthy is one.

It seems to me like a lot of the newer refs are obsessed with stand ups.

If I hear "lets work" or "improve your position" when the guys have been on the ground for less than 60 seconds, it makes me want to rip my hair out.

Post #12   12/16/13 10:43:51AM   

Come at me bro

Bubbles Avatar
5




Career record: 1120-670
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
1460
9368 posts
Joined 10/09

Posted by VILLIN

No I mean the constant shouting of commands at the fighters, the lectures he feels the need to give one of the fighters every time he separates the action and the several injuries he has caused by full out tackling fighters while stopping a fight. I don't deny that he makes less screw ups than other referees but you'd have to be blind and deaf to think he's unobtrusive.


when has this happened?

_______________________________________
The best cure for insomnia is a lot of sex. Even if it doesn't end up putting you to sleep, you don't mind so much

Men be careful, female sexual predators are using a date rape drug called a Blowjob to trap men into scams called relationships.

Post #13   12/16/13 6:09:28PM   

Michael_Corleone
In Full Mount

Michael_Corleone Avatar
Career record: 862-449
Season: 42-23 (#172)
Bankroll: $445 (#1606)
Location: Private
186
771 posts
Joined 4/11

Posted by Bubbles


Posted by VILLIN

No I mean the constant shouting of commands at the fighters, the lectures he feels the need to give one of the fighters every time he separates the action and the several injuries he has caused by full out tackling fighters while stopping a fight. I don't deny that he makes less screw ups than other referees but you'd have to be blind and deaf to think he's unobtrusive.


when has this happened?




The only time I can think of is UFC 10, I believe. He broke Brian Johnston's nose by accident after a brutal knockout.

Post #14   12/16/13 7:11:09PM   

frizzzlecake
MMA Sensei

frizzzlecake Avatar
Career record: 405-250
Season: 33-19 (#1071)
Bankroll: $2,190 (#776)
Location: your f***ing nightmare
352
1549 posts
Joined 5/12

Posted by Michael_Corleone


Posted by Bubbles


Posted by VILLIN

No I mean the constant shouting of commands at the fighters, the lectures he feels the need to give one of the fighters every time he separates the action and the several injuries he has caused by full out tackling fighters while stopping a fight. I don't deny that he makes less screw ups than other referees but you'd have to be blind and deaf to think he's unobtrusive.


when has this happened?




The only time I can think of is UFC 10, I believe. He broke Brian Johnston's nose by accident after a brutal knockout.




I really want to see a gif of this.

Post #15   12/17/13 2:25:02AM   
 
 
Log In  
Username:

Password:

Keep me logged in