Today's Topics Unanswered Topics Avatar Bets Search PM's My Props Member Directory Premium Members Recent Polls Subscriptions Rules
 
Sponsors
 

Hypothetical: Frankie Edgar vs Gilbert Melendez at Featherweight [POLL]

At FW, Who Wins?
Forum Opinion Poll
Frankie Edgar 23 85%
Gilbert Melendez 4 15%
 
Hypothetical: Frankie Edgar vs Gilbert Melendez at Featherweight [POLL]
Posted By Message

Slight Reach Advantage

Poor_Franklin Avatar
7






Career record: 1239-678
Season: 47-18 (#27)
Bankroll: $855 (#1477)
Location: Ronda Rousey's Guard
1335
5935 posts
Joined 6/11
Edgar is dropping to 145. Melendez is considering it. Who do you think would win and how?

They're both so similar to me that I don't know who I would pick.

Last edited 12/5/12 10:41PM by Poor_Franklin
Edit note/reason: n/a

_______________________________________
MMA Events Attended:
FFI Ultimate Chaos Lashley vs Sapp - Biloxi
FN22 Marquardt vs Palhares - Austin
FN25 Shields vs Ellenberger - New Orleans
Bellator 73- Tunica


Never Trust A Man Who Does Not Make All Of His Picks

UFC 151: Never Forget

Post #1   12/5/12 10:39:56PM   

sparky
Heavyweight Champ

sparky Avatar
16















Career record: 2532-1375
Season: 48-17 (#1)
Bankroll: $1,435 (#1110)
Location: Ontario "905"
988
5422 posts
Joined 7/07
I think Frankie takes it on decision. Frankie will be the much quicker fighter and I dont think Gil will be able to keep up. I see Frankie controlling the fight if it hits the mat I think it will be Frankie who scores with the takedowns. This would be an awesome fight. Good match making P_F

Last edited 12/5/12 10:48PM by sparky
Edit note/reason: n/a

Post #2   12/5/12 10:46:45PM   

FastKnockout
Heavyweight Champ

FastKnockout Avatar
6





Career record: 1473-814
Season: 45-20 (#336)
Bankroll: $2,805 (#380)
Location: Mississippi
1550
10807 posts
Joined 9/10
I've never been a fan of Melendez's top 3 ranking. He's lucky if he's top 5. IMO Frankie would beat him at FW and LW.

Last edited 12/5/12 11:44PM by FastKnockout
Edit note/reason: n/a

Post #3   12/5/12 11:43:28PM   

jae_1833
Heavyweight Champ

jae_1833 Avatar
5




Career record: 2332-1467
Season: 42-23 (#312)
Bankroll: $3,445 (#179)
Location: California
978
7646 posts
Joined 7/07
I think Fankie has proven what he does to boxer/wreslters with a bit of a size advantage. I wouldn't be immediately as interested in this fight as I am in some of Frankie's potential match ups. I also think Frankie would win, outstriking Gil with his speed and movement. I think he could avoid/reverse take downs to his advantage as well.

Post #4   12/6/12 12:21:20AM   

Randy is King

Budgellism Avatar
13












Career record: 2515-1432
Season: 45-20 (#91)
Bankroll: $2,022 (#841)
Location: Canada
1727
13265 posts
Joined 4/07
Edgar all day imo. I'm not convinced Gil is a top 10 Lightweight. I think he'll be a top 10 Featherweight no problem but I can't see where Frankie loses to him.

Post #5   12/6/12 12:50:06AM   

Come at me bro

Bubbles Avatar
5




Career record: 1120-670
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
1460
9368 posts
Joined 10/09
I picked Edgar but this would be a really close fight. Melendez is definitely a top 5 LW but I think Edgar's speed and footwork would give him the edge

_______________________________________
The best cure for insomnia is a lot of sex. Even if it doesn't end up putting you to sleep, you don't mind so much

Men be careful, female sexual predators are using a date rape drug called a Blowjob to trap men into scams called relationships.

Post #6   12/6/12 1:00:46AM   

Steady MODdin'

cowcatcher Avatar
5




Career record: 2365-1349
Season: 37-27 (#739)
Bankroll: $1,171 (#1310)
Location: Milwaukee
1684
7719 posts
Joined 1/07
I'm with the majority, but like Bubbs and others said before me, I think it's a close ass fight. Frankie is the faster of the two and that's the big edge in this fight as far as I'm concerned. I don't see either finishing each other, it's just a 15 or 25 minute whirlwind with no one being dominant, but Frankie doing more than Gil.

Post #7   12/6/12 3:17:13AM   

KE Released in MAtter

airkerma Avatar
5




Career record: 871-505
Season: 45-19 (#146)
Bankroll: $1,010 (#1413)
Location:
1023
4389 posts
Joined 1/10
Frankies boxing is what puts him ahead of everyone who can't out muscle him...and essentially all of those who can outmuscle him within reason.

Post #8   12/6/12 9:55:04AM   

kingsmasher
BANNED

Career record: 258-155
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Orlando
166
1750 posts
Joined 3/11
Its so hard to gauge Gilbert for the mere fact is.....Who has he fought that could be a top 5 guy in the UFC? His opponents as of late are not even top 15 in the UFC...

He just won a split decision....Not impressed...I do like his resume for FW though...by resume I mean he can wrestle and has a good reach...good standup...

Post #9   12/6/12 12:10:42PM   

Come at me bro

Bubbles Avatar
5




Career record: 1120-670
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Hamilton, Ontario
1460
9368 posts
Joined 10/09

Posted by kingsmasher

Its so hard to gauge Gilbert for the mere fact is.....Who has he fought that could be a top 5 guy in the UFC? His opponents as of late are not even top 15 in the UFC...

He just won a split decision....Not impressed...I do like his resume for FW though...by resume I mean he can wrestle and has a good reach...good standup...


Josh Thomson, if healthy, is easily a top 10 LW

_______________________________________
The best cure for insomnia is a lot of sex. Even if it doesn't end up putting you to sleep, you don't mind so much

Men be careful, female sexual predators are using a date rape drug called a Blowjob to trap men into scams called relationships.

Post #10   12/6/12 2:14:19PM   

sbulldavid
Heavyweight Champ

sbulldavid Avatar
3


Career record: 1241-724
Season: 42-22 (#398)
Bankroll: $4,406 (#113)
Location:
332
3411 posts
Joined 3/08
I think Gilbert is underrated because of his big mouth, his striking and defense are really good now days, he's on the same level as Frankie but Frankie's stamina is where he's got the edge in my book, still I would take Melendez.

Post #11   12/6/12 9:09:47PM   

Combat Sport and Fitness

tcunningham Avatar
1
Career record: 466-317
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Mean streets of Enumclaw, WA
601
3181 posts
Joined 9/09
haha 21-2 for frankie. i agree

Post #12   12/7/12 2:29:05AM   
 
 
Log In  
Username:

Password:

Keep me logged in