Today's Topics Unanswered Topics Avatar Bets Search PM's My Props Member Directory Premium Members Recent Polls Subscriptions Rules
 
Sponsors
 

BJJ Gi or No Gi

BJJ Gi or No Gi
Posted By Message

Geoffo
Standup Guy

Geoffo Avatar
1
Career record: 176-119
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Vancouver, BC
65
395 posts
Joined 10/11
What do you guys prefer?
Gi or No gi?

Pros and cons of each?

come at me.

Post #1   11/7/11 3:27:25PM   

DeadHead988
MMA Sensei

DeadHead988 Avatar
Career record: 367-289
Season: 1-2 (#1665)
Bankroll: $2,725 (#431)
Location: Waukesha, WI
331
1435 posts
Joined 8/10
No Gi: More fun, more realistic, more translatable to MMA, better scoring system, more fun to watch.

Gi: One of those old traditions that's only kept around for the sake of tradition

Post #2   11/7/11 5:10:39PM   

postman
Heavyweight Champ

postman Avatar
2

Career record: 743-418
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Delmont ,Pa
1023
6112 posts
Joined 6/07

Posted by DeadHead988

No Gi: More fun, more realistic, more translatable to MMA, better scoring system, more fun to watch.

Gi: One of those old traditions that's only kept around for the sake of tradition



More realistic? I disagree you get into a street fight and there is a good chance dude will be wearing pants shirt maybe a jacket. Knowing how to use his clothes to sweep, or choke him is a major advantage.

I no longer compete in timed No gi matches due to the fact scoring sucks. I will only compete in no time limit sub only tourneys. I have not done any Gi training I go to a MMA gym and they only offer no gi at this time. I will agree it transitions better.

Post #3   11/7/11 7:00:12PM   

ghandikush
MMA Sensei

ghandikush Avatar
Career record: 118-71
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
213
1376 posts
Joined 7/11

Posted by DeadHead988

No Gi: More fun, more realistic, more translatable to MMA, better scoring system, more fun to watch.

Gi: One of those old traditions that's only kept around for the sake of tradition



I was a Bravo no gi nutthugger. I was a wrestler too so no gi there.

I have come to realize that even though the gi is shit it absolutely helps a persons understanding of JJ.

For me it is just as much fun in gi because I am small and dexterious with my whole body against biggies. I do think the kimono design is inapplicable bullhit though for the street.

Post #4   11/7/11 10:24:33PM   

Combat Sport and Fitness

tcunningham Avatar
1
Career record: 466-317
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Mean streets of Enumclaw, WA
601
3181 posts
Joined 9/09
i prefer no-gi but gi definetly has its place. they really compliment eachother if you can train both. im a blue belt but since i started fighting the gi hasnt seen nearly as much action.

Post #5   11/8/11 3:10:34AM   

RyanC
MMA Sensei

RyanC Avatar
Career record: 472-317
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Hastings, MN
128
1290 posts
Joined 8/09
I've trained both. Currently doing much more nogi since I'm at a 10th Planet gym, but I started out in the gi, at a Rickson affiliate school. We've got some guys, including myself, that still like to throw the gi on, and my coach actually still trains in it 2-3 days a week.

I enjoy both gi and nogi. They are just different.

Post #6   11/11/11 5:05:16PM   

Geoffo
Standup Guy

Geoffo Avatar
1
Career record: 176-119
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Vancouver, BC
65
395 posts
Joined 10/11

Posted by postman


Posted by DeadHead988

No Gi: More fun, more realistic, more translatable to MMA, better scoring system, more fun to watch.

Gi: One of those old traditions that's only kept around for the sake of tradition



More realistic? I disagree you get into a street fight and there is a good chance dude will be wearing pants shirt maybe a jacket. Knowing how to use his clothes to sweep, or choke him is a major advantage.

I no longer compete in timed No gi matches due to the fact scoring sucks. I will only compete in no time limit sub only tourneys. I have not done any Gi training I go to a MMA gym and they only offer no gi at this time. I will agree it transitions better.



Whats the diff. between No Gi scoring and Gi scoring?

Post #7   11/14/11 1:09:28AM   

Legattacks
Learning to Sprawl

Career record: 0-0
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
0
13 posts
Joined 3/13
No Gi... Other than rank I do not see why the Gi is needed. No Gi transfers to the street and MMA better than Gi.

Post #8   3/29/13 9:30:50PM   

The Playground OG

george112 Avatar
2

Career record: 1070-712
Season: 33-32 (#851)
Bankroll: $4,846 (#85)
Location: Lake Jackson, Texas
1003
5103 posts
Joined 1/07
prefer no gi.

however going with a gi its alot easier to get the takedown.love incorporating judo if/when we start standing

_______________________________________
Ron Paul 2016

Post #9   3/29/13 10:32:14PM   

Paleojiujitsu
Learning to Sprawl

Career record: 0-0
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: St. Amant
1
3 posts
Joined 4/13
No GI - more basic, easier on cardio, better for fight prep


GI - more technical, tighter game, harder on cardio, more sanitary

Post #10   4/2/13 8:44:29PM   

bjj1605
Heavyweight Champ

bjj1605 Avatar
6





Career record: 1402-821
Season: 26-16 (#1141)
Bankroll: $1,001 (#1415)
Location: Chicago
671
3172 posts
Joined 10/07
I've never seen a naked street fight. Not even a mostly naked one.

No-gi is only more realistic if you're planning to get in a fight at the beach or if you are an MMA fighter. The ability to grip a person's clothing to control them is invaluable in a self-defense situation. Same goes for gi-chokes. Can you imagine cross choking someone with their winter-coat? Zipper strangulation FTW.

Even if you do plan on doing MMA, a good base in gi is a good idea before you train no-gi. No-gi is faster paced and much more slippery (yucky, I know.) You lose out on a lot of technique if you only train without the gi, especially in escaping submissions. You may be able to get away with muscling your way out of an arm-bar when you roll at the end of training session, but when you aren't sweaty and you're going against a technical guy in MMA, you can't get away with being sloppy.

At Team Curran the rule is you need 6 months of training in gi before you can come to no-gi class. Officially, fighters are required to train both, but many only usually do no-gi. I find those guys much easier to deal with than the fighters who train both.

Post #11   4/8/13 2:40:14PM   

Legattacks
Learning to Sprawl

Career record: 0-0
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
0
13 posts
Joined 3/13

Posted by bjj1605

I've never seen a naked street fight. Not even a mostly naked one.

No-gi is only more realistic if you're planning to get in a fight at the beach or if you are an MMA fighter. The ability to grip a person's clothing to control them is invaluable in a self-defense situation. Same goes for gi-chokes. Can you imagine cross choking someone with their winter-coat? Zipper strangulation FTW.

Even if you do plan on doing MMA, a good base in gi is a good idea before you train no-gi. No-gi is faster paced and much more slippery (yucky, I know.) You lose out on a lot of technique if you only train without the gi, especially in escaping submissions. You may be able to get away with muscling your way out of an arm-bar when you roll at the end of training session, but when you aren't sweaty and you're going against a technical guy in MMA, you can't get away with being sloppy.

At Team Curran the rule is you need 6 months of training in gi before you can come to no-gi class. Officially, fighters are required to train both, but many only usually do no-gi. I find those guys much easier to deal with than the fighters who train both.



I do not think you can compare street cloths to a Gi. A normal coat does not give you the ability to pull on it like a Gi without ripping.

Post #12   4/8/13 4:27:29PM   

bjj1605
Heavyweight Champ

bjj1605 Avatar
6





Career record: 1402-821
Season: 26-16 (#1141)
Bankroll: $1,001 (#1415)
Location: Chicago
671
3172 posts
Joined 10/07

Posted by Legattacks

I do not think you can compare street cloths to a Gi. A normal coat does not give you the ability to pull on it like a Gi without ripping.



Definitely not the EXACT same thing. And obviously there are different kinds of clothing. A winter jack or a hoody though can work like a gi in a lot of ways. A t-shirt much less so.

In either case, the friction is important too. Its not JUST the grips.

Post #13   4/9/13 4:27:43PM   

Page
Learning to Sprawl

Career record: 0-0
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
0
2 posts
Joined 5/13
Don't care anymore, except when it gets hotter than hell in our gym, then no gi, hah.

Post #14   5/16/13 10:32:57AM   

aussiemma
MMA Sensei

aussiemma Avatar
2

Career record: 541-289
Season: 41-24 (#210)
Bankroll: $1,095 (#1356)
Location: sydney, australia
307
1347 posts
Joined 1/12
i've been training bjj for about 4 months now and currently prefer gi. I train out of gracie sydney in alexandria. They tend to favour the gi obviously as it is a gracie gym but they do have no gi classes available every night.

i do respect both gi and no gi equally though, anyone who says gi is stupid is in fact stupid themselves. they are just different and should both be respected.

Post #15   6/2/13 6:29:07AM   
 
 
Log In  
Username:

Password:

Keep me logged in