Pick'em Leagues: THE BIG SHOW CASUAL BEST OF THE REST Single Event PvP: FANTASY POOLS Betting Leagues: THE BIG SHOW BEST OF THE REST

MIr vs. Noguira II Question

Print  
  Page 1 of 2     1     2  
Posted By Message

bsh162007

MMA Regular

bsh162007 Avatar
 
 
 


 
 
Posts:67
Career:51-51
Joined:May 2009
Camp: Team Tarp
Chips:
4
Just wanted to ask this and get everyones opinion but does anyone seriously think that NOG has a chance against Frank I mean as much as everyone likes to hate on Frank you got to give him his credit where its do I mean the guy is a beast of a man. The first time wasnt a fluke and the whole staph thing i think got blown up too much. But i think this fight will be even more of a beating than the first time because Frank is only getting better and stronger I would also like to say that im not putting NOG down he is a legend of the sport and i have much respect for him but i even think with NOG in his prime MIr takes it.

Post #1   8/4/10 8:05:55PM   

Jackelope

Go ahead, MOD my day

Jackelope Avatar
4



 
 
 


 
 
Posts:7,224
Career:864-486
Joined:Jan 2007
Chips:
1,202
I wouldn't pick Mir over Prime Nog, but I will pick today's Mir over today's Nog.

I really hope this turns into a ground battle at some point and Nog proves Mir (nor hardly anyone else in the UFC) doesn't want to be on the ground with him.

Last edited 8/4/10 8:08PM server time by Jackelope
Edit note/reason: n/a

Post #2   8/4/10 8:08:04PM   

sbulldavid

Heavyweight Champ

sbulldavid Avatar
3


 
 
 


 
 
Posts:3,666
Career:1,468-851
Joined:Mar 2008
Camp: Playground Legends
Chips:
375
I don't think a prime Nog beats Mir. But we've never really seen Mir have to defend against submissions, but I believe most of the middle tier fighters would defeat most of yesterday's greats consistently because they know what to avoid and how to game plan against other fighter. Still, Nog is never out of a match until he's out cold or the clock runs out, so we'll wait and see, you can't doubt his heart.

Post #3   8/4/10 8:39:11PM   

Caesarrrr

Standup Guy

 
 
 


 
 
Posts:377
Career:77-70
Joined:Mar 2010
Chips:
29
I actually want this to go to the ground. I think Mir is too smart for that, and Nog hasn't got the takedowns, but it'll be a much more exciting fight.

Post #4   8/4/10 9:48:01PM   

ace_of_god

Learning to Sprawl

ace_of_god Avatar
 
 
 


 
 
Posts:48
Career:151-115
Joined:Aug 2009
Camp: Grande Cajones Fight Camp
Chips:
4
I think Mir will come out and show off his skills which have continued to develop. I think his stand up is much more effective then Nogs, and if it does hit the ground its cause Nog is dazed. But this is MMA and nothing is for certain.

Post #5   8/4/10 11:37:56PM   

Jackelope

Go ahead, MOD my day

Jackelope Avatar
4



 
 
 


 
 
Posts:7,224
Career:864-486
Joined:Jan 2007
Chips:
1,202

Posted by sbulldavid

I don't think a prime Nog beats Mir.



It's definitely an interesting subject of debate. The reason why I believe Prime Nog would win is this-

I think Nog's boxing combined with his iron chin are overlooked by today's fans. You gotta remember Nog started every single fight he was ever in on the feet, and he somehow managed to find a way to get opponents who are much tougher to get to the ground than Mir is down there and into his world.

Once on the ground Nog is a master of the position battling game. Of the two people I can think of who dominated positions and avoided submissions against Nog the names are Fedor and Barnett. Barnett is known for his incredible ground control, most notably his submission defense and ability to smother from the top. Fedor is just Fedor.

Mir has never been known as a position dominating grappler. Of all his submissions the only one I can think of that came from a dominant position was his submission over Antoni Hardonk. Which, if I'm not mistaken, came on a reversal of position. (I could be wrong but I believe Mir was on the bottom for a portion of that fight. Against Hardonk of all people)

Here are Mir's submission wins in the UFC off the top of my head-

Kongo- submitted off his back in a guillotine
Lesnar- Submitted off his back in a knee bar
Hardonk- already mentioned
Sylvia- submitted in Arm bar off his back (Broke Tim's arm)
Tank Abbot- submitted off his back via toe hold
That one other dude- submitted in a Mir lock. Somewhat of a shoulder lock done ... you guessed it... off his back.

Compare that to Nog's position dominant BJJ game. I mean Nog made Randy, a master of positional dominance, look like a novice on the ground with his reversals. Nog is a true BJJ master. I give Mir plenty of props... where offensive oriented BJJ is concerned there are few who can match Mir's arsenal in MMA, but in the position and overall BJJ game I have to say Prime Nog would more than likely run roughshod over Mir.

Post #6   8/5/10 2:40:00AM   

Pookie

Remember Paul Herrera

Pookie Avatar
8
 
 
 


 
 
Posts:9,605
Career:1,910-1,061
Joined:Apr 2007
Camp: The Ringers
Chips:
1,787
Nog in his Prime beats the best Mir that ever fought. It's not even close.

_______________________________________
BJ Penn beat Frankie Edgar more times than Benson Henderson beat Frankie Edgar.

Post #7   8/5/10 6:32:41AM   

KingCmb

Standup Guy

KingCmb Avatar
1
 
 
 


 
 
Posts:473
Career:935-862
Joined:Mar 2009
Chips:
166

Posted by Jackelope


Posted by sbulldavid

I don't think a prime Nog beats Mir.



It's definitely an interesting subject of debate. The reason why I believe Prime Nog would win is this-

I think Nog's boxing combined with his iron chin are overlooked by today's fans. You gotta remember Nog started every single fight he was ever in on the feet, and he somehow managed to find a way to get opponents who are much tougher to get to the ground than Mir is down there and into his world.

Once on the ground Nog is a master of the position battling game. Of the two people I can think of who dominated positions and avoided submissions against Nog the names are Fedor and Barnett. Barnett is known for his incredible ground control, most notably his submission defense and ability to smother from the top. Fedor is just Fedor.

Mir has never been known as a position dominating grappler. Of all his submissions the only one I can think of that came from a dominant position was his submission over Antoni Hardonk. Which, if I'm not mistaken, came on a reversal of position. (I could be wrong but I believe Mir was on the bottom for a portion of that fight. Against Hardonk of all people)

Here are Mir's submission wins in the UFC off the top of my head-

Kongo- submitted off his back in a guillotine
Lesnar- Submitted off his back in a knee bar
Hardonk- already mentioned
Sylvia- submitted in Arm bar off his back (Broke Tim's arm)
Tank Abbot- submitted off his back via toe hold
That one other dude- submitted in a Mir lock. Somewhat of a shoulder lock done ... you guessed it... off his back.

Compare that to Nog's position dominant BJJ game. I mean Nog made Randy, a master of positional dominance, look like a novice on the ground with his reversals. Nog is a true BJJ master. I give Mir plenty of props... where offensive oriented BJJ is concerned there are few who can match Mir's arsenal in MMA, but in the position and overall BJJ game I have to say Prime Nog would more than likely run roughshod over Mir.




this is a great way to put it however i pick prime mir over prime nog because while hes really yet to have to show it he imo has it in him to defend subs the only example i have is that while you are right hardonk was on top mir not only reversed position but hardonk actually had a kimora in (if i remember correctly)

*also jackalope mir subbmitted roberto travan in the ufc also


while most of mirs subs do come of his back he sets most them up with strikes withch is something i dont think nog or most pure grapplers can handle

Last edited 8/5/10 8:28AM server time by the-king
Edit note/reason: n/a

Post #8   8/5/10 8:27:59AM   

ace_of_god

Learning to Sprawl

ace_of_god Avatar
 
 
 


 
 
Posts:48
Career:151-115
Joined:Aug 2009
Camp: Grande Cajones Fight Camp
Chips:
4
I don't even think we have seen Mir's Prime with the exception of the Carwin fight, which he got decimated. Frank Mir has really turned the corner since his loss to Lesnar.

Post #9   8/5/10 9:16:33AM   

Pookie

Remember Paul Herrera

Pookie Avatar
8
 
 
 


 
 
Posts:9,605
Career:1,910-1,061
Joined:Apr 2007
Camp: The Ringers
Chips:
1,787
I disagree, He put on the weight to do better specifically against wrestlers, but it ended up slowing down his striking and his mobility. Making his striking edge harder to exploit. And to top it off he still got smothered by the wrestlers he beefed up to fight against. The mass increase hurt his chances in every single conceivable way.
His best fight weight is at 250.

____

Now i think Nog beats Mir (both in their primes) because of the way Frank loses confidence in his striking when you hit him repeadedly. Nog may not hit Heavyweight hard, but hes sharp, quick, and he throws combo's extremely well. I think he'd break Mir's will via the volume of connected shots while Mir tries to single shot him.

On the ground, i see it as a wash. Nog has the better transitions, Mir is more likely to get the takedown. Niether fighter is going to sub the other.

But on the feet, i give a definite advantage to prime Nog.

_______________________________________
BJ Penn beat Frankie Edgar more times than Benson Henderson beat Frankie Edgar.

Post #10   8/5/10 10:43:04AM   

1daveufc

Standup Guy

1daveufc Avatar
2

 
 
 


 
 
Posts:447
Career:612-433
Joined:Dec 2008
Camp: East Coast Pitbulls
Chips:
23
I think mir takes this again by tko! nog has no head movement any more and just keeps walking forwad and mir is getting better with his striking a see it same as last time.

Post #11   8/5/10 1:48:08PM   

prozacnation1978

Heavyweight Champ

prozacnation1978 Avatar
4



 
 
 


 
 
Posts:13,187
Career:2,530-1,341
Joined:Jul 2007
Camp: Dark Horse
Chips:
935
I picked nog over mir first time and was shell shocked on how good mir looked
Mir is bigger and his striking is better. Other hand nog has a glass chin now
Crazy knowing in all his fights in ufc he has only managed to sub out one guy only
I really wanted to see nog vs cro cop. But. I gotta go with mir
Question is. If nog loses. Will he retire or get cut??

He still has some bouts. Left. Nelson vs nog. Nog vs cro cop
Nog vs gonzaga. Nog vs yvel. Maybe even nog vs lesnar one day.

Post #12   8/6/10 12:45:40PM   

thebestout

Learning to Sprawl

 
 
 


 
 
Posts:31
Career:693-436
Joined:Aug 2007
Camp: M Town Hard Hitters
Chips:
2
Maybe even Nog vs Lesnar one day? Man are you serious?

Post #13   8/10/10 1:02:11AM   

ChrisSabal

Go Cubs Go!

ChrisSabal Avatar
2

 
 
 


 
 
Posts:1,269
Career:807-565
Joined:Jun 2010
Camp: TKO
Chips:
250

Posted by thebestout

Maybe even Nog vs Lesnar one day? Man are you serious?



Think about it Lesnar loses the title he has a chance to fight Nog. So there ya go!

Post #14   8/10/10 3:35:54AM   

BustedKnuckle

MMA Sensei

BustedKnuckle Avatar
3


 
 
 


 
 
Posts:1,445
Career:659-381
Joined:Sep 2009
Chips:
92
I have such a respect for Nog thats i find it very hard to pick against him. I think if it goes tot he ground......he has a very legit chance of beating Mir. But if he chooses to stand and box Frank......it's the same result as the first fight!

Post #15   8/11/10 5:39:21PM   
 
  Page 1 of 2     1     2