Today's Topics Unanswered Topics Avatar Bets Search PM's My Props Member Directory Premium Members Recent Polls Subscriptions Rules
 
Sponsors
 

Former Heavyweight champion Tim Sylvia ready to return to the UFC

  Page 2 of 3     1     2     3  
Former Heavyweight champion Tim Sylvia ready to return to the UFC
Posted By Message

GSPCanada
Standup Guy

1
Career record: 637-415
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
61
412 posts
Joined 3/08
someone explain to me why we are all ok with guys like mark coleman and chuck liddell returning to the ufc but the consensus is that tim cant just walk back into the ufc?

Post #16   9/2/09 3:23:59PM   

MODular Approach

grappler0000 Avatar
24























Career record: 1249-696
Season: 35-17 (#36)
Bankroll: $1,569 (#964)
Location:
2434
9908 posts
Joined 3/07

Posted by GSPCanada

someone explain to me why we are all ok with guys like mark coleman and chuck liddell returning to the ufc but the consensus is that tim cant just walk back into the ufc?



To be honest, I'm not sure that Coleman earned his spot. I think it's possibly the UFC trying to take care of a HOF'er...especially after the obvious pity bonus he got for FOTN against Shogun. As far as Chuck goes, if he wasn't (1) the biggest name in MMA (2) putting it all on the line every fight and (3) only losing to top competition, then I could see cutting him too...but just like Wandy, they'll both have a place in the UFC until they retire. Also, Tim just lost to an out of shape 50 year old boxer, who was fighting MMA for his 2nd time ever...and lost in 9 seconds to top it off. It'll be a while before people forget about that one.

Post #17   9/2/09 3:42:34PM   

BACK OFF WAR CHILD!

emfleek Avatar
11










Career record: 1186-614
Season: 19-17 (#1170)
Bankroll: $4,221 (#89)
Location: Fort Wayne, IN
2216
18641 posts
Joined 11/07

Posted by grappler0000

Also, Tim just lost to an out of shape 50 year old boxer, who was fighting MMA for his 2nd time ever...and lost in 9 seconds to top it off. It'll be a while before people forget about that one.



Not to mention the fact that Tim came in to that fight weighing over 300 lbs, which could indicate that he's not taking his health or the sport seriously.

_______________________________________
"I'm like the superhero coming in with the anti-bullsh*t." - Nick Diaz

Post #18   9/2/09 3:47:03PM   

tallica62
MMA Sensei

tallica62 Avatar
Career record: 1086-696
Season: 33-19 (#462)
Bankroll: $1,778 (#850)
Location: San Diego
141
1024 posts
Joined 6/07
"There'd be some great fights if I was back in the UFC. Me against Frank (Mir), me against (Antonio Rodrigo) Nogueira, me against Randy (Couture). Those three right there. The two guys I lost to (Nogueira and Couture) that were all great fights the first time."

notice how he didnt say Brock...the #1 HW right now...

Sylvias days are over...although as some people mentioned, you never know with the UFC....like baroni, coleman.... whos next, dan severn?

Post #19   9/2/09 3:50:15PM   

Twenty20Dollars
Heavyweight Champ

5




Career record: 847-533
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
1196
12772 posts
Joined 6/07
Tell Timmy to go crap his pants elsewhere.

Post #20   9/2/09 4:22:22PM   

motorboatensob
Standup Guy

motorboatensob Avatar
Career record: 470-300
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Louisville KY
42
289 posts
Joined 1/07

Posted by GSPCanada

someone explain to me why we are all ok with guys like mark coleman and chuck liddell returning to the ufc but the consensus is that tim cant just walk back into the ufc?




Because Chuck lost to the number 1,3,and 5 ranked LHW in the world and Tim lost to a 48 year old man nuff said.

Post #21   9/2/09 4:38:42PM   

PABLOMAFIOSO
In Full Mount

PABLOMAFIOSO Avatar
3


Career record: 903-608
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: England
60
529 posts
Joined 6/07
Sylvia is a dreamer!
The heavyweight division was getting criticism when he was the champ. The reason Randy made a comeback was to prove he could own that division. He is not getting a shot in the UFC again.
If Timmy came back to the UFC try to name someone currently in the division who wouldn't wipe the floor with him.......GO!

Post #22   9/2/09 5:30:51PM   

StorminYourman
Belt Contender

StorminYourman Avatar
1
Career record: 540-332
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
156
930 posts
Joined 1/07
Big Tim will need some impressive wins to get back in the UFC.His recent wins have been quite lacklaster.He fought an exciting fight against Big Nog but he lost. Come to think of it his recent losses have been quite exciting however that will not get back in the UFC.Anyhow the guy brought it upon himself really fighting not to lose instead of trying to finish.

Post #23   9/2/09 6:28:54PM   

Sinister
BANNED

Sinister Avatar
Career record: 22-17
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Cedarville, OH and Connellsville, PA
29
466 posts
Joined 8/09
If he could beat Mcully or Struve, I dont see why they wouldnt keep him at the lower end of the division. He has to win a few fights though, hes a mess right now courtesy of Fedor

Post #24   9/2/09 7:03:06PM   

StorminYourman
Belt Contender

StorminYourman Avatar
1
Career record: 540-332
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location:
156
930 posts
Joined 1/07

Posted by Sinister

If he could beat Mcully or Struve, I dont see why they wouldnt keep him at the lower end of the division. He has to win a few fights though, hes a mess right now courtesy of Fedor


Ireally do not see Mcully staying in the UFC HW division for too long.

Post #25   9/2/09 7:26:17PM   

prozacnation1978
Heavyweight Champ

prozacnation1978 Avatar
3


Career record: 1232-646
Season: 32-20 (#132)
Bankroll: $2,887 (#195)
Location: san diego
862
11587 posts
Joined 7/07
u shouldn't have left timmy!!!
now u gotta beg to get your job back!!!

Post #26   9/2/09 7:27:04PM   

AchillesHeel
Heavyweight Champ

AchillesHeel Avatar
2

Career record: 594-345
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: In the cheap seats.
603
3108 posts
Joined 2/07

Posted by Sinister

If he could beat Mcully or Struve, I dont see why they wouldnt keep him at the lower end of the division.


Because he's boring to watch.

Actually, that's not entirely true. I've enjoyed watching all of his recent losses.

Post #27   9/2/09 7:48:04PM   

Sir_Karl
MMA Sensei

Sir_Karl Avatar
Career record: 1083-766
Season: 31-20 (#695)
Bankroll: $1,785 (#842)
Location: The Empire State
209
1075 posts
Joined 9/07
I think Tim's UFC days are long past. In his defense though...Fedor, Couture and Big Nog are 3 of the very best ever...worse things can happen than losing to them. As far as his fight with Mercer...Tim got his lights turned out. Mercer is a former Heavy weight boxing champion. His boxing skills are far better than any heavyweight in MMA.
Tim's only shot against Mercer would have been to take him to the ground...Mercer didn't give him that opportunity. I don't think Sylvia would fare to good against any HW in the UFC at this point. In the past...not only was Tim in better shape and a much better fighter...the level of competition was much lower.
To be honest I think Tim's luck has run out...I could be wrong though.

Post #28   9/2/09 9:35:49PM   

Rush
Laying down the beats

Rush Avatar
4



Career record: 467-329
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Canadian living in the SF Bay Area
835
6291 posts
Joined 1/07
I'll put a little more objectivity in this thread.

Reasons why Tim should not be given a shot in the UFC at this time

1) He is not exciting to watch
2) His record is 1-4 in his last 5 fights. Mind you, 3 of his losses were to top competitors. In all fairness, I am not going to crucify him too much for the Mercer loss. It was a mistake on his part, and I don't take it as a sure thing that he is now a can.
3) Tim is injury prone.
4) He doesn't have a likable personality.
5) He has shown no signs of evolution in his skill at all.
6) Failed drug test and stripped of title
7) once he started facing stronger opponents, his finishing ability evaporated.

Reasons why he should be given a second chance
1) He was a former champion

Like most of these fighters, if he can string together some convincing wins against known fighters, then I'm ok with him getting a second chance, but as of now, there is no way. That being said, even if he gets another chance he will not be able to hang with the UFC HW division now.

Post #29   9/2/09 9:51:20PM   

MMA-San
In Full Mount

MMA-San Avatar
1
Career record: 762-573
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: AZ
106
529 posts
Joined 4/09
Give him Cheick Kongo...if he wins then he can stay...if he doesn't...then we know he's gone forever.

Post #30   9/2/09 10:00:25PM   
 
 
  Page 2 of 3     1     2     3  
Log In  
Username:

Password:

Keep me logged in