Should There Even be a Hot Bout for the Affliction: Banned Event? |
| Posted By |
Message |
The Usual Suspect
Career record: 139-71
Season: 18-3 (#7)
Location: Florida
|
As stated in the title, do you think this event(Affliction: Banned) should have a hot bout? I personally think that since the picks are so lopsided that there should not be a hot bout for this event. I understand that the closest bout on the card(percentage wise) is deemed the hot bout for every event.
However, with an overwhelming 71% picking Mark Hominick and only a mere 29% picking Savant Young, I don't think there should be a hot bout. I believe that a hot bout should be A LOT closer percentage wise. There should be a % cut off for the hot bout(60-40 maybe). As with this hot bout you will either have a majority of the players get the 10+ points or a small minority. It seems unfair, if you miss this hot bout it will greatly effect your score as the majority will get the extra points. Then, if the minority picks the hot bout correctly, the majority will be left without the extra points. This would be great for the minority.  Yet, it is a closer fight than the percentages show and it is risky to go with Savant.
I am sure this will get shot down as the majority picking Mark like that it's the hot bout, but I think that it makes sense and this fight should be deemed as a regular fight and not include double the points. Well, let me know what you guys think and feel free to voice your opinions. 
Just think, if it were to drop another 9% Savant would be considered an Underdog!
Last edited 6/16/08 7:37PM by wolfman
Edit note/reason: n/a
_______________________________________
Support all of MMA, not just the UFC.
Expand your mind. Watch other organizations and evolve as an MMA fan.
L2 Points Average (4 seasons): 54.075
Primary League Points Average (2 seasons): 52.1
|
|
Post #1 6/16/08 7:36:46PM
|
# 1 In The Hood G
| 1 |  |  |
1 |
Career record: 192-104
Season: 15-6 (#1181)
Location: Pennsylvania
|
I think the hot bouts should only be when they are within 5% of each other.
60 % to 40% is too much of a gap to constitute a hot bout IMO...but thats just me.
Maybe within 10% but no more.
Last edited 6/16/08 7:51PM by 40ouncetofreedom
Edit note/reason: n/a
2 total post edits
_______________________________________
Actually, it only takes one drink to get me loaded. Trouble is, I can't remember if it's the thirteenth or fourteenth.
-- George Burns
Myspace
|
|
Post #2 6/16/08 7:48:39PM
|
Ridin the MMA WW since 02 !
Career record: 121-64
Season: 17-4 (#9)
Location: Long Beach
|
I say Yes, It's an easy Pick for me as Mark always Struggles with Wrestlers and Savant is very Skilled
_______________________________________
MMA Playground Top 25's
Top Score: TUF 6 Finale- # 10
Top Score: K-1 Olympia- # 23
Top Score: StrikeForce PBM- # 6
Top Score: Cage Rage 25- # 7
Top Score: Cage Rage 26- # 4
Top Score: UFC 87- #12
Top Score: L2 Season 2- #9
Top Earner: Dream 1- # 6
Top Earner: Cage Rage 25- # 7
Top Earner: UFC 87- #17
11 Underdog Bonus Wins
|
|
Post #3 6/16/08 7:52:37PM
|
The Usual Suspect
Career record: 139-71
Season: 18-3 (#7)
Location: Florida
|
Posted by 40ouncetofreedom
I think the hot bouts should only be when they are within 5% of each other.
60 % to 40% is too much of a gap to constitute a hot bout IMO...but thats just me.
Maybe within 10% but no more.
Yeah, I agree and if you check the site's stats you will see that most are in the 10% range or less. Just kind of threw that percentage out there as I am sure everyone's view on how close the hot bout should be is different and gave it a more liberal range.
Thanks for the quick replies guys!
hotrodttt: Yeah, that's how I see the fight right now. Yet, I still worry that Mark might pull off the win if he comes in on the top of his game. He is very inconsistent and you never know which Mark will show up.
_______________________________________
Support all of MMA, not just the UFC.
Expand your mind. Watch other organizations and evolve as an MMA fan.
L2 Points Average (4 seasons): 54.075
Primary League Points Average (2 seasons): 52.1
|
|
Post #4 6/16/08 7:59:26PM
|
ohiostate1016
MMA Sensei
Career record: 99-67
Season: 16-5 (#457)
Location: Columbus, OH
|
The only cutoff that I would put is that a Hot Bout can't have an underdog bonus. I'd say that this one is within those parameters.
|
|
Post #5 6/16/08 8:09:21PM
|
The Usual Suspect
Career record: 139-71
Season: 18-3 (#7)
Location: Florida
|
Posted by ohiostate1016
The only cutoff that I would put is that a Hot Bout can't have an underdog bonus. I'd say that this one is within those parameters.
Fair enough. It's good to read other people's opinions on why there should be a hot bout or not, rather than just seeing the results. I personally think that a Hot Bout should just be that, a "HOT" Bout. One that is TOO close to call and the percentages reflect that the fight could go either way. Essentially, to me it seems pointless to have a hot bout when the percentage difference is so large. This bout should be called the "Luke-Warm Bout"....and that's being generous. lol Yet, I know everyone has different opinions and from the poll I am clearly in the minority. 
Last edited 6/16/08 8:23PM by wolfman
Edit note/reason: typos!
4 total post edits
_______________________________________
Support all of MMA, not just the UFC.
Expand your mind. Watch other organizations and evolve as an MMA fan.
L2 Points Average (4 seasons): 54.075
Primary League Points Average (2 seasons): 52.1
|
|
Post #6 6/16/08 8:16:02PM
|
The Usual Suspect
Career record: 139-71
Season: 18-3 (#7)
Location: Florida
|
ttt
_______________________________________
Support all of MMA, not just the UFC.
Expand your mind. Watch other organizations and evolve as an MMA fan.
L2 Points Average (4 seasons): 54.075
Primary League Points Average (2 seasons): 52.1
|
|
Post #7 6/16/08 11:00:10PM
|
The Female Prodigy
Career record: 127-75
Season: 12-9 (#1708)
Location: So Cal.
|
Posted by 40ouncetofreedom
I think the hot bouts should only be when they are within 5% of each other.
60 % to 40% is too much of a gap to constitute a hot bout IMO...but thats just me.
Maybe within 10% but no more.
I agree, between 5 and 10% or I guess it would be even to 10%
Last edited 6/17/08 12:13AM by holt8081
Edit note/reason: n/a
_______________________________________
Blessed be the Lord my strength which teacheth my hands to war and my fingers to fight. Psalm 144:1...................WAR BJ
|
|
Post #8 6/17/08 12:12:48AM
|
BerndRealBad
MMA Regular
| 1 |  | |
1 |
Career record: 165-96
Season: 14-7 (#189)
Location:
|
What needs to happen is more people need to choose Mark Hominick so I can get some underdog points when Savant wins. C'mon people, pick the more well known name! And while you're at it, keep thinking Justin Levens is going to win another MMA fight ever again.
|
|
Post #9 6/17/08 3:43:37AM
|
Wins Fairly Squarely
Career record: 176-104
Season: 15-6 (#297)
Location: Cornwall, UK
|
Things dont get changed on this site so this is all pretty pointless but yes of course the hot bout should only be there with double points when its a close fight, thats a no brainer, but like i said things rarely get corrected and it will be deemed as fair and the same for everyone 
_______________________________________
WAR MMA ARMY
Banned from the forums AND Banned from sending PM's
Top Posters FOR Top Posters Badges - wolfman/juanez13/Kpro/Pookie
"Due to the sensitive nature of this forum, posters discretion is advised"
|
|
Post #10 6/17/08 6:37:00AM
|
The Usual Suspect
Career record: 139-71
Season: 18-3 (#7)
Location: Florida
|
Posted by CornishMMA
Things dont get changed on this site so this is all pretty pointless but yes of course the hot bout should only be there with double points when its a close fight, thats a no brainer, but like i said things rarely get corrected and it will be deemed as fair and the same for everyone
Yeah, it seems stupid to have a Hot Bout for an event when the percentage for the Hot Bout is not EVEN CLOSE. There are such big underdogs on the card and I understand that the rules state that it's the closest bout on the card, but seriously this is not close at all. I don't expect this to be changed this season or ever, but think there should be a cutoff for the hot bout percentage wise. So, that is why I threw it out there.
_______________________________________
Support all of MMA, not just the UFC.
Expand your mind. Watch other organizations and evolve as an MMA fan.
L2 Points Average (4 seasons): 54.075
Primary League Points Average (2 seasons): 52.1
|
|
Post #11 6/17/08 3:02:07PM
|
# 1 In The Hood G
| 1 | | |
1 |
Career record: 192-104
Season: 15-6 (#1181)
Location: Pennsylvania
|
Affliction-The most 1 sided picks on mmaplayground.com ever.
I got 4 under dogs picked to win anyways.
Last edited 6/17/08 8:50PM by 40ouncetofreedom
Edit note/reason: n/a
_______________________________________
Actually, it only takes one drink to get me loaded. Trouble is, I can't remember if it's the thirteenth or fourteenth.
-- George Burns
Myspace
|
|
Post #12 6/17/08 8:48:53PM
|
|
