Today's Topics Unanswered Topics Avatar Bets Search PM's My Props Member Directory Premium Members Recent Polls Subscriptions Rules
 
Sponsors
 

BJ Penn sends NSAC formal request to investigate Georges St. Pierre at UFC 94

THIS TOPIC HAS BEEN LOCKED Print
  Page 1 of 2     1     2  
BJ Penn sends NSAC formal request to investigate Georges St. Pierre at UFC 94
Posted By Message

Buy the ticket, take the ride

SmileR Avatar
5




Career record: 1059-618
Season: 20-12 (#1092)
Bankroll: $1,070 (#1311)
Location: My big ass bed
986
3345 posts
Joined 12/07
The legal team that represents lightweight champion BJ Penn — four days removed from a technical knockout loss to welterweight champion Georges St. Pierre at UFC 94 on Jan. 31 — today sent a formal request (not a complaint) to the Nevada State Athletic Commission (NSAC).

The three-page letter is designed to ensure that the sanctioning body engages “in a comprehensive investigation and review of the activities involving and relating to Georges St. Pierre prior to and during the bout.”

St. Pierre’s cornermen during the fight applied Vaseline to his back and shoulders, which is illegal under the rules of the sport. Ringside officials noticed the generous helping of petroleum jelly on the backside of the Canadian and sprung into action, wiping him down with towels after rounds two and three.

“Rush” isn’t giving excuses for the incident, saying it was just a minor mistake caused by the between-round frenzy. UFC President Dana White — who is taking the issue very seriously — has since blamed “stupid” cornermen (Greg Jackson and Phil Nurse) for the infraction.

The letter to the NSAC indicates that not only is greasing illegal, but it taints the reputation of the sport and jeopardizes the health and safety of those who participate in it.

Furthermore, it states the application of Vaseline put Penn at a serious disadvantage during the fight because as a Brazilian jiu-jitsu specialist, “The Prodigy” relies on his ability to apply techniques and strategies designed to immobilize or cause potential injury to his opponent.

With that ability neutralized, Penn’s attorney contends that his client was put in an environment that was both “life threatening” and “career ending.”


Link

_______________________________________
"RIP Evan Tanner, a real life trail blazer."

I was born to lead, not to read!!!!

Post #1   2/4/09 6:05:39PM   

casey64
BANNED

Career record: 208-123
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Football Field
115
2568 posts
Joined 7/07
This whole thing is way out of control.JMO

Post #2   2/4/09 6:09:29PM   

Bowen50
The Talent

Bowen50 Avatar
4



Career record: 659-381
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Long Island, NY
353
1221 posts
Joined 6/07

Posted by casey64

This whole thing is way out of control.JMO



agreed. i doubt anything is going to come of this anyway. it's just being blown way out of proportion.

Post #3   2/4/09 6:13:09PM   

tepid55
MMA Sensei

tepid55 Avatar
9








Career record: 1290-675
Season: 37-15 (#50)
Bankroll: $2,700 (#223)
Location: Texas
120
1471 posts
Joined 2/07
He's just mad because GSP beat him fair and square.

Post #4   2/4/09 6:15:11PM   

bigox420
MMA Regular

bigox420 Avatar
Career record: 614-450
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Windsor, Ontario, CANADA
4
61 posts
Joined 6/07
Penn’s attorney contends that his client was put in an environment that was both “life threatening” and “career ending.”

wow that is pretty harsh.
“life threatening” and “career ending.” lol

Post #5   2/4/09 6:16:38PM   

Boo_Radley21
Heavyweight Champ

Boo_Radley21 Avatar
Career record: 573-405
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Ontario
461
4034 posts
Joined 7/07

Posted by bigox420

Penn’s attorney contends that his client was put in an environment that was both “life threatening” and “career ending.”

wow that is pretty harsh.
“life threatening” and “career ending.” lol



BJ is starting to sound like the little tattle tale who says anything to get the other kid in more trouble.

Post #6   2/4/09 6:25:40PM   

MODular Approach

grappler0000 Avatar
24























Career record: 1249-696
Season: 35-17 (#36)
Bankroll: $1,569 (#964)
Location:
2433
9908 posts
Joined 3/07


Ringside officials noticed the generous helping of petroleum jelly on the backside of the Canadian and sprung into action...



I'm still reserving judgment, but I don't honestly remember it happening quite like that.

Post #7   2/4/09 6:30:16PM   

Deathbringer
Learning to Sprawl

Deathbringer Avatar
4



Career record: 460-253
Season: 15-5 (#1219)
Bankroll: $3,072 (#171)
Location: BC, Canada
2
21 posts
Joined 2/09
I've lost a ton of respect for BJ... I would have loved to hear him come out and admit he got beat by the better man. Instead he's going to let his lawyer claim that it was all a result of the tiny bit of vaseline that may have ended up on GSP's shoulder blade. Yeah right.

Post #8   2/4/09 6:55:01PM   

DCRage
Representin' The MA's

DCRage Avatar
4



Career record: 453-339
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Maryland
576
10684 posts
Joined 8/07
Also, it's NOT a formal complaint and the NSAC does not consider it one. So technically he's not yet asking for a protest or whatever official avenues would need to be taken to trigger one.

Post #9   2/4/09 6:59:59PM   

Jackelope
Go ahead, MOD my day

Jackelope Avatar
4



Career record: 586-330
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Getting choked out or arm barred
1202
7224 posts
Joined 1/07
I'm glad they chose this avenue to file the protest. This protects the image of the sport and ensures the level playing field. BJ is not asking for the decision to be overturned as far as I can tell. He and his camp are only doing the right things to ensure the sport maintains its purity.

As for things like "life threatening" and such, those are just legal terms that have to be thrown in with paper to push this stuff through. The only people that are blowing this out of proportion are the people on either side of the argument (be they GSP fans or BJ fans) who aren't waiting for all the facts to come through.

Post #10   2/4/09 7:05:58PM   

tuvok500
MMA Sensei

tuvok500 Avatar
33
































Career record: 1268-618
Season: 30-22 (#601)
Bankroll: $465 (#1550)
Location: Quebec city, Quebec
313
2243 posts
Joined 6/07

Posted by DCRage

Also, it's NOT a formal complaint and the NSAC does not consider it one. So technically he's not yet asking for a protest or whatever official avenues would need to be taken to trigger one.



Like i said in another post, the commissioner himself was telling that Nurse was maybe having a minuscule residual of vasoline on his hand when he touched GSP's back and shoulders.

So, if they need a guy to fall, i think Nurse gonna be the one and will probably be fine for 500$ or even only a warning.
You don't ban a guy for touching a fighter with maybe a minuscule residual vaseline on his hand, it happen at every event on a lot of fighters.

Post #11   2/4/09 7:07:41PM   

MODular Approach

grappler0000 Avatar
24























Career record: 1249-696
Season: 35-17 (#36)
Bankroll: $1,569 (#964)
Location:
2433
9908 posts
Joined 3/07

Posted by DCRage

Also, it's NOT a formal complaint and the NSAC does not consider it one. So technically he's not yet asking for a protest or whatever official avenues would need to be taken to trigger one.



I'm not saying that BJ doesn't have the right to complain, but that actually just sounds like a matter of semantics to me. If they can't overturn the ruling, what is the difference between a request and a complaint. I'm assuming they'll investigate the incident in the same manner. And I also assume they'll make the same decisions if they find any wrong doing.

I'm no expert, so I could be wrong here...so, does anyone know the difference between a request and a complaint?

Post #12   2/4/09 7:08:58PM   

GDK
MMA Regular

GDK Avatar
2

Career record: 1006-732
Season: 14-22 (#1332)
Bankroll: $1,500 (#998)
Location: Sydney
20
107 posts
Joined 7/07
Hell I thought it was all a load of hooha over nothing
I didn't see it happening during the fight
I thought people were just trying to steal Akiyama’s ‘greased lightning’ nickname, And use it in the UFC

I thought BJ was clutching at straws
Especially since he didn't make the initial complaint
Or any complaint during the fight
But I guess he was concentrating on fighting

Dana seemed pissed in his video blog
As he walked over to Rashad with a ‘what’s with the greasing’ attitude
Rashad responded with a ‘**** if I know, what are you asking me for’ type response
Dana walks away kinda all ’that’s all I needed, Fedor nearly kills Arlovski and I get a greasing scandal’

Then I saw the footage
Pretty damning if ya ask me
He didn’t finish the face smearing only to pat him of the back for good luck
He applied Vaso, then rubbed his chest, applied Vaso again, then rubbed his back. And in clear sight.
Unless GSP was suffering from a cold, and being tucked in bed, thats not on.
His corner man must have had a brain explosion
To be that stupid

Post #13   2/4/09 7:16:29PM   

RampageOwnedYou
Banned

RampageOwnedYou Avatar
1
Career record: 246-144
Season: 0-0 (#-)
Bankroll: $1,000
Location: Canada
138
937 posts
Joined 5/07
Seems to me like alot of GSP fans taking this personal. Im not a fan of either, and he did put vasoline on his back, how do you guys not see it? And it would be a good thing, if it does get addressed so we dont have to deal with this sort of thing again. Its a shame it happened, but it did. So lets all just be realistic about the situation, and stop slamming BJ and in denial that it happened, because its just getting out of hand. Not only that, why would you want this in the sport? Im sorry, but there is no need to rub a fighters back, ESPECIALLY with vasoline.
Did BJ get a rub down? The guy didnt even get any vasoline on him during the fight. So why does GSP need half a jar on him in between rounds? He was winning. lol

Just My Opinion!

Post #14   2/4/09 7:28:55PM   

Remember Paul Herrera

Pookie Avatar
8







Career record: 1256-663
Season: 29-21 (#714)
Bankroll: $3,638 (#123)
Location: You think you can tell heaven from hell?
1776
9565 posts
Joined 4/07

Posted by Jackelope

I'm glad they chose this avenue to file the protest. This protects the image of the sport and ensures the level playing field. BJ is not asking for the decision to be overturned as far as I can tell. He and his camp are only doing the right things to ensure the sport maintains its purity.

As for things like "life threatening" and such, those are just legal terms that have to be thrown in with paper to push this stuff through. The only people that are blowing this out of proportion are the people on either side of the argument (be they GSP fans or BJ fans) who aren't waiting for all the facts to come through.




all of the people saying they've lost respect for BJ penn because of him addressing the issue, or losing respect for Gsp for "greasing" are either ill-informed or simply acting childish about the whole matter.

_______________________________________
BJ Penn beat Frankie Edgar more times than Benson Henderson beat Frankie Edgar.

Post #15   2/4/09 7:58:58PM   
 
 
  Page 1 of 2     1     2  
Log In  
Username:

Password:

Keep me logged in