My Worlds MMA lightweight Rankings...Let me know what you think

MMAPlayground.com » MMA General » General MMA Talk » My Worlds MMA lightweight Rankings...Let me know what you think
bt155lbs
1/16/09 4:07:39AM

1
BJ Penn


2
Shinya Aoki


3
Sean Sherk


4
Eddie Alvarez


5
Kenny Florian


6
Hayato Sakurai


7
Tatsuya Kawajiri


8
Josh Thompson


9
Gilbert Melendez


10
Tyson Griffin

lochie
1/16/09 4:36:57AM
yeah not bad but im really not sure to many contenders these days
StriderXero
1/16/09 7:06:45AM

Posted by bt155lbs


1
BJ Penn


2
Shinya Aoki


3
Sean Sherk


4
Eddie Alvarez


5
Kenny Florian


6
Hayato Sakurai


7
Tatsuya Kawajiri


8
Josh Thompson


9
Gilbert Melendez


10
Tyson Griffin





sorry to mention, but your missing Hellboy and JZ
mentalcase
1/16/09 7:09:27AM
1 B.J. Penn
Last Fight: 5/24/2008 [UFC] 13-4-1 259

2 Shinya Aoki
Last Fight: 12/31/2008 [K-1] 19-3-0 237

3 Kenny Florian
Last Fight: 11/15/2008 [UFC] 11-3-0 231

4 Satoru Kitaoka
Last Fight: 1/4/2009 [WVR] 24-8-9 228

5 Joachim Hansen
Last Fight: 7/21/2008 [DREAM] 19-7-1 211

6 Sean Sherk
Last Fight: 10/25/2008 [UFC] 35-3-1 173

7 Eiji Mitsuoka
Last Fight: 1/4/2009 [WVR] 15-6-2 164

8 Jim Miller
Last Fight: 12/10/2008 [UFC] 13-1-0 154

9 Gesias Cavalcante
Last Fight: 4/29/2008 [DREAM] 18-2-1 151

10 Eddie Alvarez
Last Fight: 12/31/2008 [K-1] 15-2-0 141

Gipper
1/16/09 10:04:55AM
the lw's are the hardest to rank you can argue for days about the order from #2-#15.
cowcatcher
1/16/09 10:46:08AM
1) penn
2) sherk
3) aoki
4) hansen
5) JZ
6) alvarez
7) florian
8) kawajiri
9) kitaoka
10) josh thomson

thats my list, but it certainly is highly debatable, a guy like eiji, or ishida, or even tyson griffin could very well be on there too. the division is just stacked.
ohiostate1016
1/16/09 8:38:49PM
Not trying to be mean, but I think that we've discussed in the past that rankings are always subjective and that nobody really cares about another's rankings.

Again, not trying to be mean or bash, just pointing out something that has been mentioned a million times.
Mr_Death
1/16/09 10:34:36PM

Posted by cowcatcher

1) penn
2) sherk
3) aoki
4) hansen
5) JZ
6) alvarez
7) florian
8) kawajiri
9) kitaoka
10) josh thomson

thats my list, but it certainly is highly debatable, a guy like eiji, or ishida, or even tyson griffin could very well be on there too. the division is just stacked.



I like this list, except I would move hansen down a couple of spots.
Jackelope
1/16/09 11:15:24PM
The OP's list is definitely missing JZ and Hellboy, but like others have said- LW is hard to figure out because virtually anybody in the top 20 could move to the top 5 within a fight or two. Sucks the JZ vs. Hellboy fight got called off because that would have cleared up some of that mess. Well, maybe a little bit anyway.

You've got guys like Stevenson and Franca who could move right back into a top 10 discussion with solid showings. I know some people will resent that, but we've already seen it happen several times over the years. Gleison Tibau, Frankie Edgar, Gray Maynard, and even Roger Huerta are guys that have been in top 10 discussions before, too.

I agree that all the names listed so far are better than most the ones I have mentioned, but still.. people have placed the latter names into top 10's before. So in the end its all subjective, and I'd say your list is pretty solid minus the JZ and Hellboy picks
higdon10
1/17/09 11:23:05AM
Penn
Aoki
JZ
Related Topics