Posted by quezocrema0032
People who think sherk can beat penn ... are fans who dont do there research ... whos sherks biggest wins ? Keno flow ?Hemres Fancas ? Karo twice ? Nick Diaz ? tell me when i get there .... while pens wins Hughes (which he beat 3 out of 4 rounds they fought) Gomi Jens Pulver Din Thomas Serra ... the only guy he beat that is really good is kenflo while penn beat many more names ... lets be honnest ... penn stops hughes take down attempts ... he will stop sherks ... sherk is gona get desperate and eventually penn will take his back 2nd rounc Rear naked choke
Ok, so BJ has beaten Hughes... 4 years ago next month.
BJ lost to Hughes last year. Rib injury or not, he didn't go into the fight injured. The injury occured in the fight, and that obviously contributed to his loss, but it didn't contribute any more or less than a fighter who loses a fight by Dr. stoppage due to a cut. A win is a win, and a loss is a loss. Big deal if he won 3 out of 4 of the rounds, it only takes 1 round to win a fight anyway. I agree (and used to feel the same way), if Penn hadn't hurt his ribs, he probably would have won that fight... but that's not how it went. By the way, I think Sherk has better take-downs than Hughes.
Since you brought up his win over Jens, and appearantly we are considering fights over 2 years ago as being relevant... Jens beat BJ in 2002. You can't use the fact that BJ beat Hughes 4 years ago, and that he beat Jens recently without saying Jens beat BJ 6 years ago (next month).
As a matter of fact, the noteable wins you bring up about BJ in reference to this are:
Hughes: Already mentioned 4 years ago, Lost last fight
Gomi: over 4 years ago
Serra: won decision over 5 years ago
Thomas: won decision 6 1/2 years ago
Pulver: Lost 6 years ago, won last fight.
IMO none of these are relevant, except for the fact that he beat Pulver recently, and lost to Hughes recently. He has lost the last 2 of the 3 fights he has had in the UFC, and 3 of his 4 losses have come in the last 3 1/2 years.
You act like Sherk has made no accomplishments either... Ok, how can you not think the win over Hermes Franca was great? Hermes had just won 8 straight fights, all of which he finished. Then there is KenFlo... he may not have a bunch of professional fights under his belt, but you can't say this guy isn't a force. Every one of his wins have been because he has finished. The only 3 guys he has ever lost to were Fickett, Sanchez, and Sherk. So to say beating KenFlo is no accomplishment, basically shows that you are speaking pure opinion and just don't want to give Sherk any credit, or credit to any fighter Sherk has beaten. As far as Karo, and Nick... well this post has gotten long, but I doubt there would be many people on here that would agree with you in thinking that these guys are push-overs.
In either case, sorry to come down on your, but don't tell me that because I think Sherk can beat Penn that I need to do my research. Have you done yours?