Posted by GlancyMMA
I don't want to disrespect Rampage Jackson, he is definately a first class fighter and has done great things this year.
However, Fighter of the Year? Granted he toppled Lidell from his thrown and made a hell of an enterance into the UFC.
But with 3 fights this year.
- Mavin Eastman being one I would like to discount as a bi-entry into the organization.
- the Lidell fight was a good solid performance
- but with a decision over Hendo.... (again noting this is quite a feat.)
I don't think this should overshadow Anderson Silva's year with 2 title defence TKOs (minus Lutter for being a dumbass) including a second dominating win over Rick Franklin and a war with Marquardt. Also submitting a BJJ Black Belt (Lutter) in dominating fashion.
I think this has got to be Silva's year. He really performed against 3 quality opponents (MMA Weekly has it right).
Posted by GlancyMMA
I don't want to disrespect Rampage Jackson, he is definately a first class fighter and has done great things this year.
However, Fighter of the Year? Granted he toppled Lidell from his thrown and made a hell of an enterance into the UFC.
But with 3 fights this year.
- Mavin Eastman being one I would like to discount as a bi-entry into the organization.
- the Lidell fight was a good solid performance
- but with a decision over Hendo.... (again noting this is quite a feat.)
I don't think this should overshadow Anderson Silva's year with 2 title defence TKOs (minus Lutter for being a dumbass) including a second dominating win over Rick Franklin and a war with Marquardt. Also submitting a BJJ Black Belt (Lutter) in dominating fashion.
I think this has got to be Silva's year. He really performed against 3 quality opponents (MMA Weekly has it right).
Posted by CornishMMA
Posted by GlancyMMA
I don't want to disrespect Rampage Jackson, he is definately a first class fighter and has done great things this year.
However, Fighter of the Year? Granted he toppled Lidell from his thrown and made a hell of an enterance into the UFC.
But with 3 fights this year.
- Mavin Eastman being one I would like to discount as a bi-entry into the organization.
- the Lidell fight was a good solid performance
- but with a decision over Hendo.... (again noting this is quite a feat.)
I don't think this should overshadow Anderson Silva's year with 2 title defence TKOs (minus Lutter for being a dumbass) including a second dominating win over Rick Franklin and a war with Marquardt. Also submitting a BJJ Black Belt (Lutter) in dominating fashion.
I think this has got to be Silva's year. He really performed against 3 quality opponents (MMA Weekly has it right).
Nope, sorry i strongly disagree
Chuck and Hendo are much better PBP fighters than Franklin and Nate, no way can you give it to Silva instead imho!
The only possible should be Randy as the Sylvia fight was fantastic but the GG fight eclipsed that achievement and while theres just 2 fights they are more impressive than Rampages 2 main ones IMO