Referee Dan Miragliotta's latest performance strictly by the book

MMAPlayground.com » Community » MMA News Share Forum » Referee Dan Miragliotta's latest performance strictly by the book
SmileR
1/18/09 5:19:03PM
Referee Dan Miragliotta is certainly no stranger to controversy.

Beginning with his performance during the "EliteXC: Primetime" bout between Kevin "Kimbo Slice" Ferguson and James Thompson, seemingly every decision made by Miragliotta in the cage is open to some degree of criticism.

So it should have been of little surprise when an accidental eye-poke in the closing minute of Saturday night's UFC 93 main-event bout between Dan Henderson vs. Rich Franklin left Miragliotta's performance open to public evaluation.

Except as Nick Lembo, legal counsel to the New Jersey Athletic Control Board, told MMAjunkie.com (www.mmajunkie.com), Miragliotta handled the situation exactly as MMA's current guidelines dictate.

"With accidental fouls, such as an eyepoke -- which this sounds kind of like the Scott Smith vs. Robbie Lawler fight -- the referee sees the eyepoke, and the first thing the referee has to determine is was it accidental or was it intentional," Lembo said. "At that point he assesses the fighter and the referee makes a decision whether or not to bring in the doctor."

The controversy began when Henderson clearly jammed fingers on his left hand deep into Franklin's right eye. The blow was accidental, and Henderson immediately apologized. Franklin was clearly affected, but Miragliotta initially refused to allow "Ace" any time to recover.


Link
Wolfenstein
1/19/09 1:32:44AM
Maybe they're suddenly deciding to enforce the 2 minute rule, because there have been numerous instances where the fighter has received 5 minutes to recover, and has always been the standard I have seen used, such as Tommy Speer vs George Sotiropoulus,

If the rule is 2 minutes then okay, but enforce it that way consistently. To act like this is the way things have always been done, is just plain false.
MMAcca
1/19/09 8:24:59AM
Miragliotta didn't seem to know what to do initially.....
finnish_line
1/19/09 9:40:41AM

Posted by Wolfenstein

Maybe they're suddenly deciding to enforce the 2 minute rule, because there have been numerous instances where the fighter has received 5 minutes to recover, and has always been the standard I have seen used, such as Tommy Speer vs George Sotiropoulus,

If the rule is 2 minutes then okay, but enforce it that way consistently. To act like this is the way things have always been done, is just plain false.




I think something that might have factored in to the 2 minutes instead of 5 was that they were almost out of PPV time.
casey64
1/19/09 9:58:59AM

Posted by MMAcca

Miragliotta didn't seem to know what to do initially.....




Yeah he was running around the octagon asking someone on the outside if we give rich time.
Related Topics