The Official 2012 NFL Season Thread

MMAPlayground.com » Off Topic » Off Topic » The Official 2012 NFL Season Thread
« Previous Page | Next Page »
Twenty20Dollars
8/13/12 1:23:52PM
Does anyone know if teams get any compensation if their draft picks don't sign, like specifically their first round draft picks?

I was watching Hard Knocks and it was saying Tannehill was prepared to re-enter the draft before he signed.

I know in baseball teams get a compensation draft pick if their 1st rounder doesn't sign, but not sure about football. Does the drafting team hold any rights to the guy they drafted?

It just seems crappy if the team can't sign him and that person re-enters the draft and the drafting team gets nothing from their 1st round that year.
ChrisSabal
8/13/12 3:25:12PM

Posted by Twenty20Dollars


Posted by ChrisSabal


Posted by Twenty20Dollars

I'm still in baseball mode, but I'll go ahead and predict division and wildcard winners.

AFC
North: Ravens
East: Patriots
South: Texans
West: Chiefs
Wildcards: Steelers, Titans

Sleepers: Bills, Jets

NFC
North: Packers
East: Cowboys
South: Falcons
West: 49ers
Wildcards: Lions, Eagles

Sleepers: Panthers, Bears



Bears aren't much of a sleeper this year with Brandon Marshall, Forte and Cutler and still a great defense. They should either win the division or take a wild card spot.



But only 8-8 last year. Culter sometimes questionable and tough division.



They were also one of the best teams in the league last year until Cutler got hurt and thats why they finished 8-8.
Poor_Franklin
8/13/12 4:09:24PM

Posted by Twenty20Dollars

Does anyone know if teams get any compensation if their draft picks don't sign, like specifically their first round draft picks?

I was watching Hard Knocks and it was saying Tannehill was prepared to re-enter the draft before he signed.

I know in baseball teams get a compensation draft pick if their 1st rounder doesn't sign, but not sure about football. Does the drafting team hold any rights to the guy they drafted?

It just seems crappy if the team can't sign him and that person re-enters the draft and the drafting team gets nothing from their 1st round that year.



very good Q. i looked up articles on Tannehill's situation before signing & Crabtree w/ the 49ers when he was threatening to re-enter the draft & none spoke of any compensation for the teams. Doesnt mean they dont. I just couldnt find one. BSB might know
Twenty20Dollars
8/13/12 4:40:38PM

Posted by Poor_Franklin


Posted by Twenty20Dollars

Does anyone know if teams get any compensation if their draft picks don't sign, like specifically their first round draft picks?

I was watching Hard Knocks and it was saying Tannehill was prepared to re-enter the draft before he signed.

I know in baseball teams get a compensation draft pick if their 1st rounder doesn't sign, but not sure about football. Does the drafting team hold any rights to the guy they drafted?

It just seems crappy if the team can't sign him and that person re-enters the draft and the drafting team gets nothing from their 1st round that year.



very good Q. i looked up articles on Tannehill's situation before signing & Crabtree w/ the 49ers when he was threatening to re-enter the draft & none spoke of any compensation for the teams. Doesnt mean they dont. I just couldnt find one. BSB might know



All I could find was on Bo Jackson, drafted by Bucs didn't sign and played baseball and re-entered draft and drafted by raiders.

But nothing about compensation.
Kpro
8/13/12 8:19:30PM
As far as i know the team does not get compensation for a player drafted that doesn't sign. You have until near the end of the year to sign them though so if it's a huge issue you have months to work out a sign and trade if that's the issue or at least months to convince the player they'll only get drafted lower after sitting out football for a year. If they havent' signed by the deadline near the end of the year they can re-enter the next year's draft. Once you declare your eligibility you cannot go back to college unless you go undrafted (as far as I know), so Tannehill if he hadn't signed would've had to hold out the entire year from any football (since the drafting team owns his rights) and re-enter the next year's draft. The players union and owners are on the same side though as far as players holding out an entire year and sitting on the couch to re-enter next years draft.
BlueSkiesBurn
8/13/12 9:21:45PM

Posted by Twenty20Dollars


Posted by Poor_Franklin


Posted by Twenty20Dollars

Does anyone know if teams get any compensation if their draft picks don't sign, like specifically their first round draft picks?

I was watching Hard Knocks and it was saying Tannehill was prepared to re-enter the draft before he signed.

I know in baseball teams get a compensation draft pick if their 1st rounder doesn't sign, but not sure about football. Does the drafting team hold any rights to the guy they drafted?

It just seems crappy if the team can't sign him and that person re-enters the draft and the drafting team gets nothing from their 1st round that year.



very good Q. i looked up articles on Tannehill's situation before signing & Crabtree w/ the 49ers when he was threatening to re-enter the draft & none spoke of any compensation for the teams. Doesnt mean they dont. I just couldnt find one. BSB might know




All I could find was on Bo Jackson, drafted by Bucs didn't sign and played baseball and re-entered draft and drafted by raiders.

But nothing about compensation.



No, you get dick. The most famous situation of this is Manning-Rivers. Manning was actually drafted by San Diego, but refused to play for them. The Chargers, knowing they would get dick because they fully believed Manning would sit out as promised and re-enter, found a club that really wanted Peyton's little brother and convinced them to draft Plan B (Phillip Rivers) and then did a trade.

You get nothing. Sometimes teams will get compensatory picks, but only from the team to whom they traded the disgruntled draftee. And those picks are usually their way of making sure they didn't end up with nothing.

The NFL, as an organization, does not give shit. They figure you ought to know who you're drafting and that due diligence should prevent this from ever happening. The only time it really does is when a player doesn't reveal his preferences until after he's been drafted by someone he hates. Rarely happens, but when it does, they almost always find a way to just do a draft-and-trade.
BlueSkiesBurn
8/14/12 12:39:05AM
Also, fuck Tannehill. That dude isn't even worth the headache of dealing with him. He's only recently become a full-time QB and the dude didn't do anything at Texas A&M to indicate that he's worth this trouble.

People are acting like his 3,744 passing yards were some sort of accomplishment in the Big XII. My grandmother could start for Texas Tech and throw for 3,800 yards.
ChrisSabal
8/14/12 12:44:23AM

Posted by BlueSkiesBurn

Also, fuck Tannehill. That dude isn't even worth the headache of dealing with him. He's only recently become a full-time QB and the dude didn't do anything at Texas A&M to indicate that he's worth this trouble.

People are acting like his 3,744 passing yards were some sort of accomplishment in the Big XII. My grandmother could start for Texas Tech and throw for 3,800 yards.



well Tannehill signed so I guess he was worth the headache. I am just upset we(Dolphins) drafted Tannehill because Barkley is coming up in this draft and I think the Dolphins are bad enough where they could end up getting him.
BlueSkiesBurn
8/14/12 1:09:50AM

Posted by ChrisSabal


Posted by BlueSkiesBurn

Also, fuck Tannehill. That dude isn't even worth the headache of dealing with him. He's only recently become a full-time QB and the dude didn't do anything at Texas A&M to indicate that he's worth this trouble.

People are acting like his 3,744 passing yards were some sort of accomplishment in the Big XII. My grandmother could start for Texas Tech and throw for 3,800 yards.



well Tannehill signed so I guess he was worth the headache. I am just upset we(Dolphins) drafted Tannehill because Barkley is coming up in this draft and I think the Dolphins are bad enough where they could end up getting him.



I'm not sure Miami would finish with a record that was crappy enough to get Barkley even without Tannehill. They play the NFC West (the crappiest division in all of fooball) & the AFC South (the 2nd crappiest division in all of football). Add in the fact that they have games with the Raiders & Bengals, and they were never going to be in the mix for Barkley. Trust me when I say that the Bengals will not repeat last year's success.

The Dolphins might be shitty, but they were never in the Blow It for Barkley sweepstakes.
ChrisSabal
8/14/12 2:00:41AM

Posted by BlueSkiesBurn


Posted by ChrisSabal


Posted by BlueSkiesBurn

Also, fuck Tannehill. That dude isn't even worth the headache of dealing with him. He's only recently become a full-time QB and the dude didn't do anything at Texas A&M to indicate that he's worth this trouble.

People are acting like his 3,744 passing yards were some sort of accomplishment in the Big XII. My grandmother could start for Texas Tech and throw for 3,800 yards.



well Tannehill signed so I guess he was worth the headache. I am just upset we(Dolphins) drafted Tannehill because Barkley is coming up in this draft and I think the Dolphins are bad enough where they could end up getting him.



I'm not sure Miami would finish with a record that was crappy enough to get Barkley even without Tannehill. They play the NFC West (the crappiest division in all of fooball) & the AFC South (the 2nd crappiest division in all of football). Add in the fact that they have games with the Raiders & Bengals, and they were never going to be in the mix for Barkley. Trust me when I say that the Bengals will not repeat last year's success.

The Dolphins might be shitty, but they were never in the Blow It for Barkley sweepstakes.



I don't know about that. We have no QB. No WRs. No HB. Our defense is still solid but not as good as it once was. We are a mess of a team and it certainly won't surprise me if we end up being one of the worst teams in the league.
BlueSkiesBurn
8/14/12 2:56:45AM

Posted by ChrisSabal

I don't know about that. We have no QB. No WRs. No HB. Our defense is still solid but not as good as it once was. We are a mess of a team and it certainly won't surprise me if we end up being one of the worst teams in the league.



Reggie Bush might disagree with you about not having a RB. Look, at the end of the day you need around 2-3 wins to even have a shot at the #1 overall pick. Barkley will be the #1 pick. There's not a QB in this draft that has his tools, his experience, his proven ability to win, and a solid head on their shoulders. That alone is enough to convince a team to take him #1 despite anything else that may happen.

Even if USC has a 10 win season, which would be crappy by our standards, Barkley will still emerge as a Heisman candidate with enormous potential. This doesn't even begin to describe the stock Barkley will have if USC meets their expectations.

I can find at least 4 wins on the Dolphins schedule. Arizona is a complete shitstorm. John Skelton actually is looking like he's going to run that team moving forward and that, like Cassel, Kolb was a bad investment. On a side note, I think that Kolb and Cassel's horrid outputs after the contracts given is going to change how backups with only one solid year are viewed, but I digress.

Arizona & Cincinnati are potential wins. The Rams are anybody's guess. Indianapolis is likely headed for rough sledding. Tennessee, Seattle, and Jacksonville are all potential wins, and I cannot fathom the Dolphins going winless in a division with as many question marks as the AFC East.

There are 7 very winnable games for the Dolphins outside of the AFC East. The NFL is probably as wide open as it ever has been.; I can't think of a single team that is a clear cut favorite out of the gate. I honestly think that the Dolphins won't come anywhere near 7 wins, but I think they would win too many to have any reasonable shot at Barkley.
BlueSkiesBurn
8/14/12 3:09:27AM
You have to go back to 2003 before you can find a season where there wasn't at least ONE team with 2 or fewer wins. I cannot picture a scenario where the Dolphins only win 2 games this season. They play WAY too many team in shitty conferences. 8 of their games are against the two worst conferences in the NFL. That doesn't even count games against the Raiders, Bengals, and Bills.

If Miami had a much harder schedule than the one they have, I could see it. Unfortunately, the Dolphins' schedule is against teams that went a combined 127-129 last year. For that matter, the AFC East is a horribly weak division if you account for the fact that the Patriots have the NFL's easiest schedule, the Bills have the 3rd easiest and Miami and New York are tied for 18th and 20th most difficult schedules, respectively.

To Miami's credit, they have the hardest schedule in the AFC East, but it's really not a difficult schedule. 3 of Miami's easier opponents play absolutely grueling schedules and that could benefit the Dolphins, who will play a much easier schedule.
cowcatcher
8/14/12 3:13:48AM

Posted by BlueSkiesBurn

Reggie Bush might disagree with you about not having a RB.



Only a USC fan would believe him though...
BlueSkiesBurn
8/14/12 3:20:30AM

Posted by cowcatcher


Posted by BlueSkiesBurn

Reggie Bush might disagree with you about not having a RB.



Only a USC fan would believe him though...



Reggie Bush, Lloyd Lake, and Todd McNair can suck a gigantic member.
warglory
8/14/12 7:47:38AM
All I can say is Chandler Jones looked purdy good against the Saints.
BlueSkiesBurn
8/14/12 1:01:29PM

Posted by warglory

All I can say is Chandler Jones looked purdy good against the Saints.



I have very little faith in my Saints this year, Cody. Between this off-season, taking a million years to sign your only Super Bowl-winning QB in franchise history, the distractions, and the lack of a coach, I think we're screwed.
prophecy033
8/22/12 6:21:02PM
Lots of young QB's are getting good looks this season. Russell Wilson getting the start this weekend
ChrisSabal
8/22/12 6:36:52PM

Posted by prophecy033

Lots of young QB's are getting good looks this season. Russell Wilson getting the start this weekend



I really hope he ends up starting. It'll make me feel good that Dolphins didn't sign Flynn.
prozacnation1978
8/22/12 9:12:22PM
This year is first year ever I will be off each Sunday

Will definitely take advantage of it and watch a lot of football games
prophecy033
8/22/12 9:14:33PM

Posted by prozacnation1978

This year is first year ever I will be off each Sunday

Will definitely take advantage of it and watch a lot of football games

you better prozac, you deserve it bro
Kpro
8/23/12 5:02:40AM

Posted by ChrisSabal


Posted by prophecy033

Lots of young QB's are getting good looks this season. Russell Wilson getting the start this weekend



I really hope he ends up starting. It'll make me feel good that Dolphins didn't sign Flynn.



As a Seattle fan who has been to multiple open practices and seen both games multiple times it's truly a testament to Wilson's skills more than it is a knock on Flynn's. The first game they didn't open up the playbook for Flynn as he went 11-13 for 71 yards, and in the next game he was 6-13 for 31 (5 of the 7 incompletions were to Terrell Owens including an absolutely perfectly thrown 46 yard TD pass that TO dropped). Take away even the one drop from TO and he's 18-26 for 148 yards 1TD-1INT against first string defenses.

Flynn isn't hurting himself, Wilson is just playing lights out at 22-33 for 279 yards and 8 rushes for 92 yards with 4 total TD's & 1 pick. We'll see what happens when Wilson gets a first string defense and Flynn gets the 2nd & 3rd stringers but I truly think Wilson already is the best person to put behind center for his dynamic play if nothing else. The first QB under 6 feet drafted in the first three rounds in who knows how long yet he had the biggest hands of any QB in a draft filled with guys like the 6'8" Brock Osweiler. The man has fucking mitts, and leadership most rookies can't even imagine.

As a sidenote, the Seahawks guaranteed Flynn less money than the Dolphins guaranteed Tannehill. Flynn's contract is truly team-friendly even if he were to be a backup since the contract is so incentive laden.
ChrisSabal
8/23/12 8:20:06PM
Jim Irsay is hinting at a big trade for the Colts. Speculation is that it is either Mike Wallace or MJD.
40ouncetofreedom
8/24/12 9:17:26AM

Posted by ChrisSabal

Jim Irsay is hinting at a big trade for the Colts. Speculation is that it is either Mike Wallace or MJD.



As a Pittsburgh fan i'd sorta miss Wallace,for me to say i wouldn't miss him and say he's a douche,Would make me look like a typical fickle fan,But even though he's pretty much a burner and speed fades eventually,It does make a D respect that and opens up other guys,But doesn't look like Steelers will sign him regardless so might as well trade and get a return instead of letting him walk for nothing,But not real sure who they'd ask in return,Maybe a 1st round pick.But i think MJD would make a lot more sense for the Colts right meow.
Kpro
8/24/12 10:45:34PM
Jesus. They finally let Russell Wilson play first stringers and he goes 3 quarters and leaves the game up 44-7 at 13-19 for 185 yard with 2 TD's and no picks and 2 rushes for 58 yards. They don't even play Flynn at all. I think the QB situation is settled (it already was from my perspective, but after today there's no way you can sell Flynn as a better candidate to start over Wilson at this point, period).
cowcatcher
8/25/12 4:27:00PM

Posted by Kpro

Jesus. They finally let Russell Wilson play first stringers and he goes 3 quarters and leaves the game up 44-7 at 13-19 for 185 yard with 2 TD's and no picks and 2 rushes for 58 yards. They don't even play Flynn at all. I think the QB situation is settled (it already was from my perspective, but after today there's no way you can sell Flynn as a better candidate to start over Wilson at this point, period).




I'm so happy for Russell. He's going to shut a lot of the doubters up this year and beyond. Good for him.
george112
8/25/12 8:10:25PM
Texans at Saints


Texans are going to the Superbowl



Poor_Franklin
8/26/12 2:37:22PM
ChrisSabal
8/26/12 3:13:05PM
Vontae Davis traded from Dolphins to the Colts for 2 undisclosed draft picks.



Dolphins are getting ready to be the laughing stock of the NFL once again I guess.
thevoodooninja
8/26/12 3:31:55PM
hey chris, dont forget my browns are in the NFL
BuffaloDave
8/26/12 7:12:09PM
Bills trade for T-Jack, definitely the end of Young and Thigpen now.
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Related Topics