The problem I see with Tim is, he doesn't seem to be focused. He doesn't have that game face that fighters have. I just don't see him going to the cage with a face that says "Game On!".
After his loss to Mir, where he got his forearm broken, Tim just doesn't seem to be the same fighter. He fights to not to lose.
After his loss to Mir, he KO'ed Wes Sims (
) at Super Brawl 38. The he lost to Arlovski by submission (after getting dropped) He TKO'ed Mike Block at IFC and then the Tra KO with the headkick. He landed the lucky punch on Arlovski, after getting dropped, and then 3 straight lackluster decisions, 2 wins and a lost.
Tim has to somehow get that fire back and I think that's what Randy saw. Randy's comments of "Tim doesn't fight to finish it." might have been Randy seeing that Tim doesn't have the fire anymore.