Posted by kopower
Don't you want to understand why this man did this, and figure out a way to prevent it in the future?
So you want to study an insane person? If he is in fact insane, then there was no specific reason he did this. What can we possibly gain? Everyone that knew this guy has said he was a normal dude, and never acted out before. Go ahead and try to question him, that's fine, but I don't see how the shootings could have been prevented by previous studies of the clinically insane.
Posted by jae_1833
No medical processes have been done to show wether or not he has any illness....in fact he is 24a and never even been in counseling....why would I ignore medical science? Stop attacking me bro....first I am a Zealot and now I am a member of a political party you don't like? Dude....I don't claim any party, ever....your trying to say have mercy on a mentally unstable person, which normally would be ok, except the fact that this guy has no history of any mental condition. His parents and fellow students claim he was a little wierd, but never thought he was nutty. Seriously even if he was, learn what science you want from his autopsy. There are plenty of "mentally ill" criminals in jail already to run science projects on. Or how about this....kill all of those assholes too and do your experiments on volunteers.
Posted by Cooler
Posted by kopower
Don't you want to understand why this man did this, and figure out a way to prevent it in the future?
So you want to study an insane person? If he is in fact insane, then there was no specific reason he did this. What can we possibly gain? Everyone that knew this guy has said he was a normal dude, and never acted out before. Go ahead and try to question him, that's fine, but I don't see how the shootings could have been prevented by previous studies of the clinically insane.
Why would we want to? Because we can prevent it, warglory just said that and we have prevented it before. We can find out what triggers this, how it works on a neurological level, more in detail about how brain states work, to not understand is to want to wallow in ignorance and throw your hands up. Like I said earlier it's the equivalent of saying "demons cause sickness" when we know better and we want to study it because we want to understand and prevent sickness. It's kind of like also saying "why understand cancer, it's such a meanie".
Posted by kopower
Posted by Cooler
Posted by kopower
Don't you want to understand why this man did this, and figure out a way to prevent it in the future?
So you want to study an insane person? If he is in fact insane, then there was no specific reason he did this. What can we possibly gain? Everyone that knew this guy has said he was a normal dude, and never acted out before. Go ahead and try to question him, that's fine, but I don't see how the shootings could have been prevented by previous studies of the clinically insane.
Why would we want to? Because we can prevent it, warglory just said that and we have prevented it before. We can find out what triggers this, how it works on a neurological level, more in detail about how brain states work, to not understand is to want to wallow in ignorance and throw your hands up. Like I said earlier it's the equivalent of saying "demons cause sickness" when we know better and we want to study it because we want to understand and prevent sickness. It's kind of like also saying "why understand cancer, it's such a meanie".
I get where you are coming from, I do. It would be great if science could find a "trigger", and prevent these things from happening. However, how can you prevent something like this when somebody has never had a psychological red flag? Holmes dropping out of school may have been it, but does that warrant a trip to the Dr.? Some people don't want help, even if it's available.
Btw, sorry PF for becoming involved in totally changing the content of the thread. you started.
If the shooters signs of debilitating mental health had been more easily spotted or seen someone could've helped him or had him committed to a mental hospital. Are you actually saying we couldn't have been prevented it? it's a lot easier than it sounds trust me. Hate to use the sickness analogy again but if someone shows symptoms of an illness they are treated whether or not they feel bad or not and regardless of if they want help or not, they better if they want to live longer. Or I could use suicidal people for an example, why should we help them? why should we understand their brains if we don't want to help them? And aren't they just not help-able?
Posted by jae_1833
So, your the scientific community now? The dude has NO MENTAL ILLNESS.....he is simply an asshole. It's not that complex, proof of evil is all around you. Do you believe in anything yet unproven by science? We all do....science is not going to disprove evil, just rename it. Regardless of the reasons/excuses that is found through the investigation....I pray he gets killed in prison much like Jeffery Dahmer.
.I belive in love, hate, aliens, ghosts and a higher power all unproveable by modern science. I do have emotion connected to this in particular situation but I am also speaking logically, sure do a test, experiment on him....but kill him as an example and as a way to at least make a small attempt to alleviate the grief of the hundred or so affected by this horrible individual. And your correct I don't know him directly but I do read on the situation and talk yo people who are currently involved in the investigation. He was working on his phd and did study mental illness and i feel he will claim some sort of bs after the fact to place the blame on something other than himself. The guy has no history of mental illness and I have family with mental illness who also study it in detail, it doesn't strike those in their mid twenties without serious symptoms that have lasted several years (meaning they had it all along). The dude is evil is my way of simplifying and being pc....he is an asshole is maybe more medically more accurate. However I wont buy into some claims of instability that relieves him of responsibility or punishment.
Posted by kopower
I don't think a lot of these shootings could have been prevented. Take your example of cancer. People can go years not knowing they have it, then all of a sudden, boom, it pops up out of nowhere, and you only have a few weeks to live. One could have done everything right in their lives, eating right, no family history, exercise, etc. and still get it. I think the same could be said of mental illness. The human body is so complex, and I think things can just happen. Something can just snap on a perfectly normal person, and science may not detect it. Maybe there is something in our dna, or some biological trigger that makes these things happen, but I just find it hard to believe that finding this trigger, will prevent bad things from happening.
So let's say science does discover a mental illness trigger. what then? Does this person automatically get psychic evaluations every month to see how they're doing? Are they never allowed to purchase a firearm? Society cannot monitor people 24/7. Take my family history for example. My father's side of the family unfortunately has cancer written all over it. My grandpa died from it, and my dad, and all of his brothers and sister have had it. I know there is a high probablility I will get it one day. Maybe I have it now? Knowing this, I should be eating healthy everyday, and doing everything I can to prevent my body from getting cancer, but I don't. I should be going to the Dr. for regular check ups, but again, I don't. It's probably not a smart move on my part. Before people are labeled mentally ill, there may have been warning signs, and they chose to ignore them. I just don't see how science can prevent this, even if triggers are detected. I know you are not saying all massacres like these can be prevented. Maybe some of them could be, and that would be great.
Again, go ahead and question him, or perform various medical testing while he's awaiting his execution. The death penalty doesn't normally take place right away. Maybe we can get some useful information before his life ends. Hell, maybe knowing he might be put to death may make him talk. I kind of rambled on there, so hopefully I tackled a few of your points.
Posted by jae_1833
Hussein, Hitler, Gacy and Dahmer are pure evil.....Ghandi, Mother Teresa and George W. Bush are pure good.I belive in love, hate, aliens, ghosts and a higher power all unproveable by modern science. I do have emotion connected to this in particular situation but I am also speaking logically, sure do a test, experiment on him....but kill him as an example and as a way to at least make a small attempt to alleviate the grief of the hundred or so affected by this horrible individual.

Posted by jae_1833
Do you honestly believe Hitler was not pure evil.....I am just putting things into perspective so that you can understand my opinion.....I am sure Ghandi etc have done some minor things that were less than great but in actions you leave your legacy. This man, as with others are bad.....plain and simple.
Posted by jae_1833
So, your the scientific community now? The dude has NO MENTAL ILLNESS.....he is simply an asshole. It's not that complex, proof of evil is all around you. Do you believe in anything yet unproven by science? We all do....science is not going to disprove evil, just rename it. Regardless of the reasons/excuses that is found through the investigation....I pray he gets killed in prison much like Jeffery Dahmer.
Posted by jae_1833
Do you honestly believe Hitler was not pure evil.....I am just putting things into perspective so that you can understand my opinion.....I am sure Ghandi etc have done some minor things that were less than great but in actions you leave your legacy. This man, as with others are bad.....plain and simple.
Posted by jae_1833
You all are so new age anti religion and unable to hear me make a simple post on my opinion that I am greatly appreciating the fact that I dont know you on any personal level......hope that life of yours stays perfect and priveledged enough to always be correct and try and deny someone else of their beliefs. In short .....I'm out.
Posted by kopower
Those were interesting reads warglory. I know first hand how bad postpartum depression is, as my wife suffered through it. I had to coax her into going to the hospital, because she became so mentally drained, and physically ill. That is part of my argument. She knew she was heading downhill, yet maintained she was fine, and denied help. It wasn't until she hit rock bottom, and her family basically telling her she had to get help, that she finally did. Obviously, she was dealing with some mental issues at the time, and we could see warning signs. I think this form of depression is much different than someone that goes out and shoots strangers though. Holmes was obviously not right in the head, and maybe one point, knew he was heading down a bad path, but chose not to do anything about it. Some people get help, yet others deny it, and bad things tend to happen if left untreated. This is what I keep coming back to it seems. How could the shootings have been prevented, if the shooter never showed signs of mental illness?
Back to the main debate of should he get the death penalty. Again, this was well thought out, and planned. He may not have been in his right mind, but lives were taken. What good would rehabbing this man do? How can we ever be certain that somebody going postal, like the Colorado shootings, can be a functioning member of society, and not have a relapse, and kill again? So he stays in a mental hospital the rest of his life?What is more ethical, to turn Holmes into a human guinea pig, or take his life in return for his actions? I guess I need to here more about Holmes and the trial, in order to pass judgement. I also think it depends on the situation, and person.
Posted by jae_1833
Because no matter what I have said it keeps getting brought up that I called him evil, and that gets turned into me saying that he is possessed by the devil and religion and political parties etc....it's a shit debate that repeatedly refers back to the dark ages.....capital punishment opinions all sorts of crap....I am just not a believer in that bullshit. I was depressed so I killed a dozen people....fuck you! If your depressed, if Daddy fondled your little nuts....fuck you! I dont give two shits or a fuck! Die!!!!! NOW!!!! Just go to hell where you belong and where you put a hundred plus people....you have earned it.





Posted by aussiemma
sunshine, lollipops and rainbows, everything that's wonderful is what i feel when we're together.![]()

Posted by jae_1833
And that is my problem....putting the word criminal in quotes and saying he has no responsibility or control over his actions. It's crap....he IS a criminal and he IS responsible for the killings. I dont care if he heard, saw, played checkers with a real celestial being. I dont care if he is full blown pyschopathic schizophrenic and has adhd all rolled into one.
Posted by jae_1833
You all are so new age anti religion and unable to hear me make a simple post on my opinion that I am greatly appreciating the fact that I dont know you on any personal level......hope that life of yours stays perfect and priveledged enough to always be correct and try and deny someone else of their beliefs. In short .....I'm out.
Posted by jae_1833
Because no matter what I have said it keeps getting brought up that I called him evil, and that gets turned into me saying that he is possessed by the devil and religion and political parties etc....it's a shit debate that repeatedly refers back to the dark ages.....capital punishment opinions all sorts of crap....I am just not a believer in that bullshit. I was depressed so I killed a dozen people....fuck you! If your depressed do us a favor and kill yourself. If Daddy fondled your little nuts....fuck you! I dont give two shits or a fuck! Die!!!!! NOW!!!! Just go to hell where you belong and where you put a hundred plus people....you have earned it.
Posted by jae_1833
And that is my problem....putting the word criminal in quotes and saying he has no responsibility or control over his actions. It's crap....he IS a criminal and he IS responsible for the killings. I dont care if he heard, saw, played checkers with a real celestial being. I dont care if he is full blown pyschopathic schizophrenic and has adhd all rolled into one.